Fatal accident · United States
American Eagle Flight 4184 crashed near Roselawn
American Eagle Flight 4184, an ATR-72-212, crashed near Roselawn, Indiana, on October 31, 1994. The flight had 68 people aboard and all 68 died. The crash was caused by icing-related loss of control in weather conditions beyond the aircraft's certified icing envelope.
This is one of 6 American Eagle fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1994.
Flight 4184 lost control while descending in a hold
Flight 4184 was flying from Indianapolis to Chicago when the upset began. The aircraft was in a holding pattern and had started descending to a newly assigned altitude of 8,000 feet when it rolled without crew command, departed controlled flight, and crashed during a rapid descent near Roselawn.
The airplane was an ATR-72-212, a twin turboprop regional airliner used on short and medium routes. In general, turboprops in this class were common on feeder airline services into larger hubs, and they often operated in the same weather systems as larger jets at lower holding and approach altitudes.
Ice formed beyond the de-icing boots on the ATR-72
The ATR-72 encountered icing while in the hold. It intermittently flew through supercooled cloud and drizzle or rain drops whose size and water content exceeded the icing conditions covered by the aircraft's certification envelope.
A ridge of ice built up aft of the rubber de-icing boots on the wings. Investigators found that this led to a sudden and unexpected reversal in aileron hinge movement, which made the airplane susceptible to an unrecoverable upset. The crew could not regain control.
This accident is one example of weather-related crashes in which the weather itself was only part of the problem. The way ice accumulates on a wing can change airflow and control response very quickly, and in some cases it can produce a severe loss of control in flight rather than a steady performance loss.
Why investigators blamed design limits and oversight
Roselawn became the site of a crash that drew attention to the ATR 42 and ATR 72 in icing conditions. Investigators concluded that the design of the de-icing boot system was not sufficient to deal with the kind of wing icing that developed on this flight.
They also cited inadequate oversight by the French Directorate General for Civil Aviation. That included failure to take the corrective action needed to ensure continued airworthiness in icing conditions, and failure to provide the FAA with timely airworthiness information developed from earlier ATR icing incidents and accidents.
In plain terms, the finding on weather did not mean simple bad weather alone. It meant the airplane encountered icing conditions that triggered a control problem the aircraft was vulnerable to, and the system responsible for certifying and monitoring that risk had not addressed it in time.
The Roselawn crash changed how icing hazards were viewed
Roselawn helped change industry understanding of icing on commuter turboprops. The issue was not limited to ice visible on the leading edge. Ice that formed just beyond protected areas could still alter the wing and control behavior enough to defeat normal recovery.
After accidents of this kind, investigators and regulators typically examine certification assumptions, pilot guidance, and equipment performance together. For readers who want the official meaning of an accident finding, our page on what probable cause means explains how final conclusions are framed, and how investigators determine the cause outlines the process behind them.
Questions people ask about this accident
What caused American Eagle Flight 4184 to crash?
Flight 4184 crashed after an icing-related loss of control. Ice accreted beyond the wing de-icing boots, leading to an uncommanded roll and an unrecoverable descent.
Where did American Eagle Flight 4184 crash?
American Eagle Flight 4184 crashed near Roselawn, Indiana, in the United States.
How many people died on Flight 4184?
All 68 people aboard American Eagle Flight 4184 died. There were no fatalities on the ground.
What type of aircraft was American Eagle Flight 4184?
The aircraft was an ATR-72-212, registration N401AM, operated by American Eagle.
Related accidents
- 68 killed
No fatalities
1 killed
9 killed
6 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.