Pilot error plane crashes: what the label covers and what it hides
In the Air Crash DB database, pilot error is the assigned main cause in 931 of 4,998 accidents, the largest single category. Each accident gets one main cause. Investigators prefer the term human factors and ask why the crew acted as it did, so the label is a starting point.
How many plane crashes are caused by pilot error?
In the Air Crash DB database, pilot error is the main cause of 931 of 4,998 accidents. That is the biggest category. Unknown comes next at 809, then controlled flight into terrain at 771, mechanical failure at 619, weather at 472 and loss of control at 461.
These are counts, not rates. The database assigns one main cause to each accident, so an accident with a weather element and a crew decision appears under only one heading. Add controlled flight into terrain and loss of control, which both usually involve a crew, and the share linked to what crews did is larger still. For the full list of categories, see plane crashes by cause, and for how we assign them, how we handle the data.
Why investigators avoid the words pilot error
Pilot error means a crew action or inaction that did not match what was needed. It describes an outcome. It does not say why it happened.
Investigators tend to prefer human factors. The question is not whether the crew made a mistake but why the mistake made sense to them at the time. A crew may have been tired, may have been trained for a different situation, or may have been working with a display that hid the problem. Calling that error and stopping there ends the inquiry early.
The term is also disputed because it can move blame onto the people who died. Accident reports usually state a probable cause and list contributing factors alongside it. What probable cause means explains the wording, and how investigators find the cause covers the process.
Loss of control, terrain and bad decisions: the main kinds
Three groups account for most crew-linked accidents.
Loss of control
The aircraft leaves its safe flight envelope and the crew does not recover it. The database holds 461 of these as the main cause. The deadliest is Air France Flight 447 in 2009 with 228 deaths, followed by Air India Flight 855 in 1978 with 213 and Aeroflot Flight 7425 in 1985 with 200. More in loss of control in flight.
Controlled flight into terrain
A working aircraft under crew control flies into the ground, a mountain or water. There are 771 in the database. The deadliest is an Islamic Revolution's Guards Corps Ilyushin Il-76MD near Shahdad, Iran, in 2003 with 275 deaths. Martinair Flight 138 in 1974 follows with 191, and Inex Adria Flight JP1308 in 1981 with 180.
Procedural and decision errors
This is the pilot error category itself: a wrong setting, a missed checklist item, a decision to continue an approach that should have been abandoned. The deadliest are American Airlines Flight 587 in 2001 with 265 deaths, China Airlines Flight 140 in 1994 with 264 and Air New Zealand Flight 901 in 1979 with 257.
Fatigue, training, automation and cockpit culture
These are the usual answers to the question of why a crew acted as it did. None of them is a cause on its own in the database, but each appears in reports.
- Fatigue. A tired crew notices less and decides more slowly.
- Training. A crew can only respond with what it has practised. Gaps in training for rare events show up in loss of control accidents.
- Automation. Automated systems reduce routine workload. When they fail or disconnect, the crew has to take over with little warning and sometimes with unclear information.
- Cockpit culture. A captain who is not questioned, or a crew that does not speak up, removes a check that would otherwise catch a mistake.
The audio from some of these flights is covered in cockpit voice recorder transcripts.
Crew resource management and the lesson of Tenerife
Crew resource management, or CRM, is training in how a crew works together: how to share information, challenge a decision, divide tasks and use every person in the cockpit as a check on the others.
It was introduced after accidents in which a crew had the information to avoid disaster and did not act on it, or in which a junior crew member saw a problem and did not press the point. The 1977 collision of two Boeing 747s on the runway at Tenerife is the accident most often linked with its introduction. The aim was to treat the cockpit as a team rather than a captain with assistants. For the other side of that kind of event, see runway incursion.
Why the share attributed to crews stays high as flying gets safer
The decade counts show pilot error as the largest single category in the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s and 1980s, and still ahead of most others later.
| Decade | Pilot error | Controlled flight into terrain | Loss of control | Mechanical failure |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1950s | 141 | 97 | 58 | 75 |
| 1960s | 154 | 91 | 60 | 85 |
| 1970s | 131 | 92 | 55 | 81 |
| 1980s | 107 | 75 | 43 | 72 |
| 1990s | 111 | 115 | 60 | 82 |
| 2000s | 88 | 86 | 59 | 81 |
| 2010s | 53 | 26 | 22 | 31 |
| 2020s | 12 | 3 | 2 | 6 |
The raw counts fall after the 1960s. The ranking changes less. One reason is that aircraft and engines have improved faster than the work of flying them, so as other causes shrink, the crew's part stands out. The 2020s figures cover a partial decade. For the wider trend, see fatal crash trends and crash statistics by year.
What to take from the numbers
Read pilot error as a category of outcome, not a verdict on character. A count of 931 says crews were the main factor in many accidents. It does not say how many were preventable by training, design or scheduling, and the database does not try to.
Unknown is the second largest category at 809, so some of the picture is missing, mostly from older accidents with little evidence. Airline and general aviation accidents differ in kind, which is covered in airline vs general aviation accidents. Official reports are the place to read the reasoning in each case, listed at official report sources.
Common questions
How many plane crashes are caused by pilot error?
In the Air Crash DB database, pilot error is the main cause of 931 of 4,998 accidents. Each accident is given one main cause.
What does pilot error mean in an accident report?
It means a crew action or inaction contributed to the accident. Investigators prefer the term human factors, and ask why the crew acted as it did.
Why do investigators avoid the term pilot error?
It describes what happened but not why. It can also place blame on the crew and end the search for causes such as fatigue, training gaps or poor system design.
What is the deadliest pilot error crash?
American Airlines Flight 587, which crashed at Belle Harbor, Queens, in 2001, with 265 deaths. China Airlines Flight 140 in 1994 had 264 deaths.
What is crew resource management?
CRM is training in how a crew works together, sharing information and challenging decisions. It was introduced after accidents such as Tenerife.
Is pilot error still the leading cause of plane crashes?
In the database it is the largest category overall at 931 accidents. Unknown is second at 809, and controlled flight into terrain third at 771.