Fatal accident · United Kingdom
British Midland Argonaut crashed on approach at Stockport
A British Midland Airways Canadair C-4 Argonaut crashed at Stockport, Cheshire, England, on June 4, 1967, while trying to land after a flight from Palma de Mallorca to Manchester. There were 84 people aboard and 72 died. The cause was fuel exhaustion.
This is one of 2 British Midland Airways fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1967.
The Argonaut lost power during the landing attempt
The Canadair C-4 Argonaut crashed during a landing attempt. The immediate problem was loss of power in both starboard engines, which led to control difficulties at a critical stage of the approach.
The aircraft was G-ALHG, operated by British Midland Airways. It had been flying from Palma de Mallorca to Manchester. Aboard were 84 people, and 72 were killed.
The stated cause was fuel exhaustion. On piston airliners of this period, fuel system management was a routine but important cockpit task, and an error there could leave an engine without usable fuel even when the airplane had completed most of the flight normally.
Fuel starvation came from inadvertent transfer in flight
The Argonaut's power loss happened because both starboard engines were starved of fuel. Investigators found that this followed inadvertent fuel transfer during the flight.
They also found that, on this type of aircraft, the fuel selector levers could be set incorrectly by even a small amount. That small mispositioning was easy to make and difficult for the pilot to recognize. After a long flight, it could empty the tank the crew expected to contain enough fuel.
This is different from a sudden structural or engine failure. The engines were deprived of fuel supply, which is why this accident sits with other cases of fuel exhaustion rather than with pure mechanical breakdowns.
Stockport impact killed no one on the ground
Stockport, in Cheshire, was where the aircraft came down after the crew lost the margin needed to complete the approach. There were no fatalities on the ground.
The accident happened in the final phase of flight, when crews have little time and altitude to deal with asymmetric power and directional control problems. Losing two engines on the same side can create severe handling difficulty, especially during a landing attempt.
That combination of power loss and handling problems often appears in discussions of loss of control in flight, although in this case the specific initiating event was the fuel system problem.
What the findings said about the aircraft type
The Canadair C-4 Argonaut was a four engined propliner used on passenger services before later jet airliners became standard. Aircraft from that era often had more manual fuel system selection than modern transport jets.
The finding here was narrow but important. A cockpit control could be moved just far enough to create a serious fuel imbalance or depletion risk, without making the mistake obvious to the pilot. That explains why the aircraft could complete a long sector and then run into trouble close to destination, when little reserve remained in the tank the crew expected to be using.
The page for how investigators determine the cause explains how investigators separate the initiating error from the final loss of control or impact sequence.
Questions people ask about this accident
What caused the British Midland Argonaut crash at Stockport?
The cause was fuel exhaustion. Investigators said both starboard engines lost power after fuel starvation caused by inadvertent fuel transfer in flight.
How many people died in the 1967 Stockport Argonaut crash?
Seventy two of the 84 people aboard were killed. There were no ground fatalities.
Where was the British Midland Argonaut flying from and to?
The aircraft was operating a flight from Palma de Mallorca to Manchester when it crashed during a landing attempt.
Why was inadvertent fuel transfer possible on this aircraft?
Investigators found that on this type the fuel selector levers could be incorrectly positioned by even a small amount. They said this was easy to do and difficult for the pilot to recognize.
Related accidents
No fatalities- 259 killed, 11 on the ground
- 118 killed
- 80 killed
9 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.