Fatal accident · United States
EgyptAir Flight 990 Boeing 767 crash off Nantucket, Massachusetts
EgyptAir Flight 990, a Boeing 767-366ER registered SU-GAP, crashed into the Atlantic Ocean about 60 miles south of Nantucket Island, Massachusetts, on 31 October 1999. All 217 people aboard, 203 passengers and 14 crew, died. The US NTSB led the investigation and published its final report in March 2002.
This is one of 9 Egyptair fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1999.
A night departure from New York ends in the Atlantic
EgyptAir Flight 990 was a scheduled service from John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York to Cairo. On 31 October 1999, at about 1:52 a.m. Eastern Standard Time, the Boeing 767 crashed into the Atlantic Ocean roughly 60 miles south of Nantucket Island, Massachusetts.
There were 217 people aboard, 203 passengers and 14 crew. None survived. No one on the ground was reported killed, since the aircraft came down at sea.
What the recorders showed
According to the NTSB factual record, the Boeing 767 began an abnormal descent shortly after reaching cruise flight. The flight data recorder and cockpit voice recorder showed that the autopilot was disengaged and that nose-down flight-control inputs were applied.
The aircraft entered a steep, high-speed descent. It was broken up or severely damaged before it hit the water. The NTSB found no evidence that another aircraft or airborne object was involved.
Weather was not a factor
The NTSB said visual meteorological conditions prevailed near the Flight 990 crash site, although the flight was on an instrument flight rules plan. Its review of weather, radar and recorder evidence found nothing to suggest weather played a part. For background on this category, see weather-related crashes.
The aircraft: SU-GAP
The EgyptAir Boeing 767-366ER, registration SU-GAP, had manufacturer's serial number 24542. Boeing delivered it new to EgyptAir on 26 September 1989, so it was about 10 years and 1 month old. The NTSB brief gives 33,354 flight hours and 7,594 flight cycles. Some secondary sources give slightly different totals.
The NTSB material does not establish any earlier accident involving SU-GAP. For wider context, see accident history by aircraft model.
The NTSB finding and Egypt's disagreement
The US National Transportation Safety Board led the investigation of the EgyptAir Flight 990 crash, because it happened in international waters within the US flight-information region. It issued its final report in March 2002.
The NTSB gave the probable cause as the airplane's departure from normal cruise flight and impact with the ocean, resulting from the relief first officer's flight-control inputs. It did not determine why he made them. Read more on what probable cause means.
The Egyptian Civil Aviation Authority disagreed and did not accept that the relief first officer's actions caused the crash. The NTSB report records repeated efforts to resolve the differences between the two agencies. The question of why the inputs were made was left open.
Minute by minute: the last half hour of Flight 990's cockpit recording
EgyptAir Flight 990 took off from runway 22R at John F. Kennedy International Airport at about 01:20 EST. The cockpit voice recorder had started at 01:19:13, as the tower passed wind information with the takeoff clearance. The climb was routine.
At about 01:40 the relief first officer proposed taking over from the command first officer, saying, "I'm not going to sleep at all." The cockpit door operated at 01:40:56, and the command first officer was then heard speaking quietly about the relief first officer's habits. At about 01:45 the command captain left for the lavatory. The relief first officer stayed at the controls.
At about 01:48, near 33,000 feet, the autopilot disconnected. The Boeing 767 began a nose-down descent and the elevator surfaces moved into a split condition. The relief first officer repeated words translated in the transcript as "I rely on God", eleven times by 01:50:08. The captain came back and asked what was happening.
At 01:50:08 the aircraft passed its maximum operating speed of about Mach 0.86 and a master warning sounded. Between 01:50:15 and 01:50:30 the captain asked about the engines and called "Pull" and "Pull with me". The recording stopped at 01:50:38 when electrical power was lost. Impact came at about 01:50:52. The page gives the crash time as about 1:52, while the recorder and radar reconstruction puts it nearer 01:50.
Parts of the Arabic recording were hard to interpret, and some words have competing translations. Published transcripts can differ from the official one.
The cockpit crew and the 1998 tail damage on SU-GAP
EgyptAir Flight 990 carried two full flight crews, a command crew and a relief crew, so four pilots were aboard. The NTSB focused on the two in the cockpit during the accident sequence, the command captain and the relief first officer.
- The command captain had about 7,850 hours total flight time, including about 2,000 hours on the Boeing 767.
- The relief first officer had about 12,538 hours total, including about 5,755 hours on the 767.
Both were experienced airline pilots, qualified for their duties. The command first officer and the other relief crew members were not in the cockpit during the final sequence.
The aircraft, SU-GAP, had one earlier event in its history. The NTSB documented tail-area damage from a 1998 ground incident at Los Angeles International Airport. Repairs were made before the accident, and the NTSB examined whether the repaired structure or the flight-control system played a part. It found no evidence that the earlier damage or repairs caused the crash. It also found no preexisting mechanical failure that explained the accident.
One figure differs from the page. This NTSB aircraft-history material gives about 33,117 flight hours and 6,895 flight cycles, against the 33,354 hours and 7,594 cycles already given on this page. The page figures stand, and the difference is not explained in the material available.
What Egypt argued, and what the NTSB asked for afterwards
After the EgyptAir Flight 990 crash, the Egyptian Civil Aviation Authority ran a parallel investigation. Its report said the evidence was not enough to identify "one particular set of events as the cause of the accident." Egypt argued that the relief first officer had not deliberately dived the airplane, that the crew was trying to regain control, and that a fault in the right elevator control system, possibly a power-control unit or related hardware, could explain the flight path. It also criticized the NTSB for reaching an intentional-action conclusion without evidence of intent or motive.
The NTSB did not accept the mechanical explanation as an adequate account of the recorded control movements and final trajectory. It did not name a motive and did not formally determine suicide. Its finding concerned the control inputs, and it said the reason for them was not determined. For the wider category, see mechanical failure crashes.
On 11 April 2000, before the final report, the NTSB issued urgent recommendations A-00-30 and A-00-31. They called for crash-protected cockpit image recorders with at least two hours of color recording covering the whole cockpit, fitted to aircraft under 14 CFR Parts 121, 125 and 135 by 1 January 2005. The recommendations were later classed "Open, Unacceptable Response", meaning the NTSB did not find the FAA's reply adequate at that time.
No source reviewed ties a mandatory 767 elevator redesign, an EgyptAir training rule or a new air traffic procedure directly to Flight 990.
Claims against EgyptAir and Boeing, and the case that stayed open
Litigation over the EgyptAir Flight 990 crash began in US courts as wrongful-death and related claims. EgyptAir agreed not to contest liability in cases where jurisdiction and venue were proper, and it kept its right to seek contribution or indemnification from others.
The Egyptian insurer MISR Insurance Company paid EgyptAir for the Boeing 767 under the hull policy and also paid compensation to victims' families. MISR then brought subrogation claims against Boeing in Egypt. It sought about $53 million for the insured value of the aircraft and about $63 million for sums paid to families, as stated in the case record. The case material reviewed gives no final judgment on the merits against Boeing. It also gives no total settlement figure for all families.
The investigative dispute did not close. No reopening of the NTSB investigation has been documented, and no later evidence has displaced its probable cause finding. The Egyptian authority's position stayed that its report named no single cause and that mechanical failure could not be excluded. The two agencies' conclusions have not been reconciled. For how reports move from draft to final, see the NTSB report timeline.
EgyptAir's earlier record
Flight 990 was not the first fatal EgyptAir accident. In December 1976, EgyptAir Flight 864, a Boeing 707, crashed on approach to Bangkok, killing all 52 aboard and 19 people on the ground. In October 1982, Flight 771, a Boeing 707, crashed while landing at Geneva.
In February 2000, after Flight 990, a different EgyptAir 767-300ER, SU-GAO, was substantially damaged in a landing attempt at Harare, Zimbabwe. See also airline safety records and how investigators determine the cause.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened to EgyptAir Flight 990?
EgyptAir Flight 990, a Boeing 767-366ER, crashed into the Atlantic Ocean about 60 miles south of Nantucket, Massachusetts, on 31 October 1999 after leaving New York for Cairo. All 217 people aboard died.
How many people died on EgyptAir Flight 990?
All 217 people aboard the Boeing 767 died, 203 passengers and 14 crew. No one on the ground was reported killed.
What caused the EgyptAir 990 crash?
The US NTSB found the probable cause was the relief first officer's flight-control inputs, which took the Boeing 767 out of cruise flight and into the ocean. It did not determine why he made them.
Did Egypt agree with the NTSB on EgyptAir Flight 990?
No. The Egyptian Civil Aviation Authority disagreed with the NTSB conclusion and did not accept that the relief first officer's actions caused the crash off Nantucket.
Was weather a factor in the EgyptAir Flight 990 crash?
No. The NTSB found no evidence that weather contributed to the accident, and visual meteorological conditions prevailed near the crash site off Nantucket.
Where did EgyptAir Flight 990 crash?
It crashed in the Atlantic Ocean roughly 60 miles south of Nantucket Island, Massachusetts, in international waters within the US flight-information region.
When did the NTSB publish its report on EgyptAir 990?
The NTSB issued its final report on the EgyptAir Flight 990 crash in March 2002.
Which aircraft was EgyptAir Flight 990?
It was a Boeing 767-366ER registered SU-GAP, delivered new to EgyptAir in September 1989 and about 10 years old at the time of the crash.
Related accidents
- 66 killed
- 53 killed, 19 on the ground
No fatalities
1 killed
9 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.