Fatal accident · Vietnam

Flying Tiger Line CL-44 struck houses near Da Nang

A Flying Tiger Line Canadair CL-44D4-1 crashed at Binh Tahi, Da Nang, Vietnam, on December 24, 1966. There were 4 people aboard and all 4 died. The crash also killed 125 people on the ground. The cause was pilot error.

This is one of 11 Flying Tiger Line fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1966.

The CL-44 came down short of Da Nang

The Canadair CL-44D4-1 was operating a cargo flight into Da Nang when it fell short of the runway during approach. It undershot by about one mile while making a radar approach at night in fog.

The aircraft then hit numerous thatched-roof houses in Binh Tahi. The impact area was inside a populated part of Da Nang, which is why the loss of life on the ground was so high. This was not a runway overrun or a veer-off after landing, the aircraft struck the ground before reaching the runway environment.

The CL-44 was a piston-engined transport derived from the Bristol Britannia line and used widely for freight work. Night arrivals in poor visibility depended heavily on instrument procedures and accurate descent control. More on that broader accident pattern is covered in weather-related crashes.

Fog, darkness and a radar approach set the scene

Da Nang was in fog when the Flying Tiger Line aircraft arrived, and the approach took place after dark. In those conditions, crews relied on a radar approach rather than visual references outside the cockpit.

A radar approach meant descent guidance was provided by controllers monitoring the aircraft's position. That kind of procedure could bring an airplane safely to the runway, but it left little margin if the descent profile was not maintained correctly. The airplane's path ended below the safe approach line before the runway was reached.

Accident reports often separate weather from crew action when both are present. Fog explained the need for instrument guidance, but the assigned cause was not weather. A short explanation of how that distinction is made appears in what probable cause means.

The assigned cause was pilot error

Binh Tahi was the site of one of Vietnam's deadliest ground-loss aviation accidents because the aircraft came down in housing rather than open land. The official cause was pilot error.

That finding placed the decisive failure in the way the approach was flown, not in a mechanical breakdown. The available account did not add a fuller public explanation beyond the short approach in fog on a night radar arrival. Why the crew descended early was never established in the material available here.

When a cargo aircraft crashed into homes, the consequences reached far beyond the crew on board. The 125 deaths on the ground showed how dangerous an undershoot could be when an airport sat close to dense residential areas. For similar cases grouped by cause, see other accidents with the same cause.

Questions people ask about this accident

What plane crashed in Da Nang on Christmas Eve 1966?

It was a Flying Tiger Line Canadair CL-44D4-1, registration N228SW, that crashed at Binh Tahi in Da Nang, Vietnam.

How many people died in the Flying Tiger Line Da Nang crash?

All 4 people aboard the cargo plane were killed, along with 125 people on the ground.

What happened on approach to Da Nang?

The cargo plane was making a radar approach in fog at night and undershot the runway by about one mile.

What caused the Flying Tiger Line CL-44 crash in Vietnam?

The assigned cause was pilot error.

  1. Flying Tiger Line Flight 739/14 disappeared over the Philippine Sea

    Western Pacific Ocean, Philippine Sea · Lockheed 1049H Super Constellation · Flying Tiger Line · N6921C

    107 killed
  2. Air Vietnam DC-4 and USAF F-4E collided near Hoi An

    Near Hoi An, Vietnam · Douglas DC-4 / USAF F-4E · Air Vietnam (South Vietnam) · XV-NUG

    74 killed, 2 on the ground
  3. U.S. Air Force C-130 Hercules shot down at Kham Duc

    Kham Duc, Vietnam · Lockheed C-130B Hercules · U.S. Air Force · 60-0297

    155 killed
  4. Learjet 60 crash in Greenacres, Florida kills all nine aboard

    Greenacres, Florida · Bombardier Learjet 60 · Private (LR60271 LLC) · N722BD

    9 killed
  5. Copa Boeing 737 and UPS Boeing 767 collide while taxiing at Miami

    Miami International Airport, Florida · Boeing 737-800 and Boeing 767 · Copa Airlines / UPS Airlines

    No fatalities

Correct this page or send a photo

Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.

By sending a photo you confirm you took it and allow Air Crash DB to publish it with your credit. We keep your message and, if you give them, your name and email, until the correction is handled. See the privacy policy.