Fatal accident · Portugal

Independent Air Flight 1851 hit Pico Alto at Santa Maria

Independent Air Flight 1851, a Boeing B-707-331B, crashed at Santa Maria in the Azores on February 8, 1989. The jet was flying from Bergamo to Santa Maria with 144 people aboard. All 144 died. The cause was pilot error.

This is one of 1 Independent Air Inc. fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1989.

Flight 1851 struck high ground on approach to Santa Maria

Independent Air Flight 1851 was nearing Santa Maria, Azores, Portugal, at the end of a flight from Bergamo - Orio al Serio. During the approach, the Boeing B-707-331B, registration N7231T, hit Pico Alto mountain while attempting to land. There were no deaths on the ground.

The impact happened at about 2,000 feet on the mountain. The aircraft was destroyed, and all 144 people on board were killed.

The crew continued descending below safe altitude

The Boeing 707 had been cleared to 3,000 feet, but the crew kept descending below that level. The approach area around Santa Maria included high terrain, so that descent put the aircraft below the minimum sector altitude.

The cockpit warning system sounded before impact. The crew did not comment on it and did not react during the seven seconds before the aircraft hit the mountain. Controlled flight into terrain accidents like this happen when an aircraft remains flyable but is flown into ground or obstacles, often during approach in poor terrain awareness or altitude control conditions.

ATC also missed the descent error

Santa Maria tower was involved in the sequence as the aircraft descended toward the island. An overlap in radio communications meant the tower did not notice that the crew had continued below the cleared altitude.

The tower also transmitted a QNH setting that was higher than the actual value. Altimeter setting matters because it affects the height indicated in the cockpit. Investigators later cited procedural errors by both the flight crew and air traffic control. For readers comparing accident findings, what probable cause means explains how official reports state responsibility, and how investigators determine the cause outlines the process behind those conclusions.

Pilot error was the stated cause

Independent Air Inc. operated the flight. The stated cause was pilot error, with the descent below minimum sector altitude central to the crash sequence.

The findings also included air traffic control procedural errors and the incorrect QNH transmission. This accident appears in the same broad category as other accidents attributed to pilot error. It is also listed among all plane crashes in 1989.

Questions people ask about this accident

What happened to Independent Air Flight 1851?

The flight hit Pico Alto mountain while attempting to land at Santa Maria in the Azores. The Boeing 707 was descending below safe altitude during the approach.

How many people died on Independent Air Flight 1851?

All 144 people aboard were killed. There were no fatalities on the ground.

What caused the Independent Air Flight 1851 crash?

The stated cause was pilot error. Investigators also cited procedural errors by air traffic control, descent below minimum sector altitude, and transmission of a QNH value higher than the actual value.

Where did Flight 1851 crash?

It crashed into Pico Alto near Santa Maria, Azores, Portugal. The collision happened during the landing approach.

  1. TWA Flight 841 broke up and crashed off Kefallinia

    Ionian Sea , off Kefallinia, Greece · Boeing B-707-331B · Trans World Airlines · N8734

    88 killed
  2. TAP Flight 425 overran the runway at Funchal

    Near Funchal, Island of Madeira, Portugal · Boeing B-727-282 · TAP (Air Portugal) · CS-TBR

    131 killed
  3. Venezuelan Air Force C-130 hit hill near Lajes

    Lajes, Azores, Portugal · Lockheed C-130H · Venezuelan Air Force · 7772

    68 killed
  4. Learjet 60 crash in Greenacres, Florida kills all nine aboard

    Greenacres, Florida · Bombardier Learjet 60 · Private (LR60271 LLC) · N722BD

    9 killed
  5. Copa Boeing 737 and UPS Boeing 767 collide while taxiing at Miami

    Miami International Airport, Florida · Boeing 737-800 and Boeing 767 · Copa Airlines / UPS Airlines

    No fatalities

Correct this page or send a photo

Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.

By sending a photo you confirm you took it and allow Air Crash DB to publish it with your credit. We keep your message and, if you give them, your name and email, until the correction is handled. See the privacy policy.