Fatal accident · India
Saudia Boeing 747 and Kazakhstan Il-76 midair collision near Charkhi Dadri
On 12 November 1996, Saudi Arabian Airlines Flight 763, a Boeing 747-168B, and Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907, an Ilyushin Il-76TD, collided in midair near Charkhi Dadri, India, about 100 km west of Delhi. All 349 people on both aircraft died. India's Lahoti Commission investigated and reported in July 1997.
This is one of 7 Saudi Arabian Airlines fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1996.
Two aircraft on conflicting tracks over Haryana
The collision between a Saudi Arabian Airlines Boeing 747 and a Kazakhstan Airlines Ilyushin Il-76 happened on 12 November 1996, at about 18:40 Indian Standard Time, near Charkhi Dadri in Haryana. The town is roughly 100 km west of New Delhi. The exact time should be read with some caution, since the published accounts do not reproduce the primary time record.
Saudi Flight 763 had left Delhi for Dhahran, with Jeddah as its onward stop. It was climbing out of the Delhi area. Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907 was flying from Chimkent (Shymkent) to Delhi and was approaching the airport. The two were in the same airspace on opposite headings.
Both aircraft were destroyed in the collision. All 349 people on board the two aircraft died, and no survivors were reported. The accounts available do not report any deaths on the ground. Weather observations for the time of the collision have not been confirmed in those accounts, so no claim about visibility or cloud is made here.
The descent below the assigned altitude
According to the reported findings of India's Lahoti Commission, the Kazakhstan Il-76 had been cleared to FL150, about 15,000 feet. It descended without authorization to around FL140 and lower. That put it at the altitude of the departing Saudi Boeing 747, and the two aircraft collided.
The inquiry attributed the descent to the Kazakh cockpit crew misunderstanding air traffic control communications. It also pointed to the crew's limited English. The crew relied heavily on the radio operator to handle contact with controllers, which meant the person talking to Delhi was not the one flying the aircraft.
Flight Safety Australia, which reviewed the accident, described the fatal injuries as multiple fractures and trauma beyond survivable limits, citing the official inquiry. Nobody on either aircraft lived through the collision or the fall.
The aircraft and the people on board
The Saudi aircraft was a Boeing 747-168B, registration HZ-AIH, flown by Saudi Arabian Airlines, then commonly called Saudia. The Kazakh aircraft was an Ilyushin Il-76TD, registration UN-76435, flown by Kazakhstan Airlines. The published accounts do not give a verified age for either airframe.
The total on board was 349 across both aircraft. A fully verified split between passengers and crew is not available in the sources consulted, so this page does not give one. The Boeing carried the large majority of the people, as a wide-body airliner on a scheduled passenger service would, while the Il-76 was a transport aircraft flying a service from Kazakhstan.
What the Lahoti Commission found
India set up a Court of Inquiry for the Charkhi Dadri collision, known as the Lahoti Commission after its chairman, Justice Ramesh Chandra Lahoti. Its report was released on 15 July 1997. The United Kingdom's Air Accidents Investigation Branch was reported to have assisted.
The principal finding, as quoted by ThePrint, was the unauthorised descent by the Kazak aircraft to FL-140 and its failure to maintain the assigned FL-150. That was the stated cause of the collision.
The commission also noted a gap in the air traffic control system. Indira Gandhi International Airport had no secondary surveillance radar at the time. The primary radar in use did not give controllers the same identification and altitude information that secondary radar provides. For more on how reports like this reach a conclusion, see how investigators determine the cause and what probable cause means.
The last eight minutes of Flight 763 and Flight 1907
Saudi Arabian Airlines Flight 763 left Delhi's Indira Gandhi International Airport at about 18:32 Indian Standard Time. After departure, Delhi Area Control told it to climb to FL140 on its westbound route. The same controllers told Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907, approaching Delhi from the east, to descend to and maintain FL150.
Shortly before 18:40, the Il-76 went down through its assigned level. The controller asked the crew to report their altitude. The Kazakh radio operator answered that the aircraft was at FL140. The controller replied with an instruction to maintain FL150. The Lahoti inquiry concluded that this instruction was misunderstood or not properly acted on.
In the final seconds the radio operator on Flight 1907 saw the Boeing 747 and told the cockpit to climb to 15,000 feet. A published account of the cockpit voice recording renders his warning roughly as "Get to 150 ... because on the 140th ...". It came too late.
The two aircraft met almost head-on at about 14,000 feet. Both broke apart and fell separately into fields near Charkhi Dadri. Aviation Safety Network-style site BAAA places the wreckage about 3 km from the town and roughly 80 km west of Delhi's airport, a shorter distance than the 100 km given elsewhere on this page. The inquiry reportedly found that the Delhi controller, V.K. Dutta, had issued the correct instructions and did not hold him responsible.
312 on the Boeing, 37 on the Ilyushin, and a radio operator who could see out
The 349 people who died at Charkhi Dadri were split very unevenly between the two aircraft. Saudi Flight 763, the Boeing 747-168B, carried 312 people: 289 passengers and 23 crew. Kazakhstan Flight 1907, the Ilyushin Il-76TD, carried 37: 27 passengers and 10 crew. The cockpit crews were three on the Saudi aircraft and five on the Kazakh one, which included a navigator and a radio operator as well as two pilots and a flight engineer.
That fifth crew position mattered. On Flight 1907 the radio operator sat behind the pilots, facing sideways, and handled all contact with Delhi. The inquiry found that direct pilot to controller communication was never established. The pilots heard the clearance only as it was relayed to them, and nobody effectively cross-checked the assigned altitude. The same seating explains why the radio operator was the person who saw the Boeing coming.
The aircraft were in or near cloud. The inquiry said this reduced the chance that either crew could see and avoid the other. Full meteorological values from the official report, such as cloud base and visibility, are not given in the material available here. The same is true of aircraft ages, flight-hour totals and individual pilot experience. The inquiry examined the aircraft, altimeters and related equipment and found no defect that caused the collision.
Fifteen recommendations and a collision-avoidance rule for India
After the Charkhi Dadri collision, the Lahoti Commission made 15 recommendations covering airspace, air traffic control, communications and aircraft equipment. Its report went to India's civil aviation minister on 15 July 1997, about eight months after the accident.
The measures most often reported are these:
- Separate inbound and outbound air corridors around Delhi, so aircraft would not meet head-on on the same route.
- Secondary surveillance radar able to give controllers reliable altitude information.
- Airborne collision-avoidance equipment on aircraft operating in Indian airspace.
- Less Delhi airspace under exclusive Indian Air Force control, allowing civil controllers to manage it more fully.
- Direct, unambiguous pilot to controller communication, and better English-language competence on international flights.
- More attention to cockpit coordination, cross-checking of clearances and crew resource management.
The clearest documented result is a requirement from India's Directorate General of Civil Aviation that aircraft flying to or from India carry an airborne collision-avoidance system. The sources do not tie all 15 recommendations to a single dated regulation, so no implementation date is given for the full set.
Saudia's argument, the compensation offer and an unfinished memorial
The Lahoti Commission held the Kazakh crew responsible for the Charkhi Dadri collision and rejected any suggestion that the Saudi crew had been at the wrong level. Counsel for Saudia argued that the records showed Delhi control had told the Boeing to stay at 14,000 feet and the Il-76 to stay at 15,000. The open question in the debate was how the clearance was received on Flight 1907, and whether the controller's phraseology played any part. The material available shows no formal dissent, no second investigation that overturned the report, and no finding of a Boeing or Ilyushin design defect.
Families of those who died brought civil claims. Saudi Arabian Airlines announced compensation of up to about 12,000 pounds per passenger family. A full settlement register, a total payout and a final split of liability between the airlines, India's air traffic service and any other party have not been made public in the sources consulted. An inquiry finding is not a damages judgment, and none covering all claims has been found.
A memorial park with the victims' names and an account of the collision has been proposed through the Charkhi Dadri district administration. No completed monument or dedication date is confirmed.
Status of the inquiry and the record since
The inquiry into the Charkhi Dadri collision closed with the Lahoti Commission report in July 1997. The sources consulted do not indicate that its findings were later overturned. Claims about later litigation or regulatory action are not confirmed by those sources, and none are made here.
The 1996 Delhi collision is widely described as the deadliest midair collision on record. It sits apart from most airline accidents because both aircraft were airliner or transport operations under air traffic control, and the loss came from a clearance not being followed. Readers comparing it with other events can look at airline safety records and why planes crash.
The retrieved sources do not give a reliable list of earlier accidents for either operator, either aircraft type or either registration, so no accident history is given for them.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened in the Charkhi Dadri midair collision?
On 12 November 1996, a Saudi Arabian Airlines Boeing 747 and a Kazakhstan Airlines Il-76 collided near Charkhi Dadri, India. All 349 people on both aircraft died.
How many people died in the Charkhi Dadri crash?
All 349 people on board the Saudi Boeing 747 and the Kazakh Il-76 died near Charkhi Dadri. No survivors and no ground deaths were reported in the sources consulted.
Where did the Saudia and Kazakhstan Airlines planes collide?
They collided near Charkhi Dadri in Haryana, India, about 100 km west of New Delhi.
What caused the Charkhi Dadri midair collision?
India's Lahoti Commission found that the Kazakhstan Il-76 descended without authorization to FL140 and did not hold its assigned FL150, hitting the Saudi Boeing 747 at that altitude.
Which flights were involved in the 1996 Delhi midair collision?
Saudi Arabian Airlines Flight 763, a Boeing 747-168B from Delhi to Dhahran, and Kazakhstan Airlines Flight 1907, an Ilyushin Il-76TD from Chimkent to Delhi.
Who investigated the Charkhi Dadri collision?
India's Lahoti Commission, chaired by Justice Ramesh Chandra Lahoti, investigated. Its report came out on 15 July 1997, with reported help from the UK Air Accidents Investigation Branch.
Did Delhi airport have secondary radar in 1996?
No. The Lahoti Commission noted that Indira Gandhi International Airport lacked secondary surveillance radar at the time, so controllers did not get the same identification and altitude data.
Is Charkhi Dadri the deadliest midair collision?
Yes. With 349 deaths, the 1996 Charkhi Dadri collision is described in the sources as the world's deadliest midair collision.
Related accidents
5 killed
241 killed, 19 on the ground- 159 killed
- 69 killed
- 92 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.