Fatal accident · United States
United and TWA airliners collided over New York
United Air Lines Flight 826 and Trans World Airlines Flight 266 collided over Staten Island and Brooklyn, New York, on December 16, 1960. There were 128 people aboard the two aircraft and all 128 died. Six people on the ground were also killed. The cause was a midair collision.
This is one of 46 United Air Lines fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1960.
Flight 826 struck Flight 266 at 5,000 feet
Flight 826, a United Air Lines Douglas DC-8-11, collided with Flight 266, a Trans World Airlines Lockheed 1049 Super Constellation, over Staten Island at 5,000 feet. The Constellation had been cleared to land at La Guardia Airport on Runway 04 when the DC-8 hit it and tore it apart.
The TWA aircraft fell at once and crashed on Miller Army Air Field on Staten Island. As the broken fuselage spun down, passengers were thrown from it. One passenger was pulled into one of the DC-8's jet engines.
The United jet stayed in the air briefly after the collision. Its crew tried to reach La Guardia for an emergency landing, but the aircraft could not maintain altitude and crashed into the streets of Brooklyn.
The collision killed everyone aboard both aircraft
New York saw wreckage fall in two boroughs, from Staten Island to Brooklyn. There were 44 people aboard the Constellation and 84 aboard the DC-8.
All 128 people on the two airliners died. Three passengers from the DC-8 died shortly after the crash, and a young boy, Stephen Baltz, survived for several days before he also died of his injuries.
Six people on the ground were killed as well. Midair collisions like this one became part of the long push toward tighter air traffic control and better separation standards. You can read more about other accidents with the same cause and how investigators sort out events like this in how investigators determine the cause.
Investigators found the United jet had gone beyond its clearance
Flight 826 drew the main focus of the investigation into how the two aircraft came together. Investigators found that the United crew entered a low-altitude holding pattern at 500 miles per hour, about twice the speed it should have been flying, then passed beyond the clearance limits and airspace assigned to the flight.
They also found that one of the DC-8's two VOR receivers was not working. The crew knew that, but did not report it to air traffic control. Investigators concluded that if controllers had been told, they probably would have provided extra radar assistance.
That combination left the DC-8 outside the space it was supposed to occupy as the TWA Constellation continued on its cleared approach.
Two very different airliners met in the same terminal area
The DC-8 and the Super Constellation represented two generations of airline travel. The DC-8 was a four-engine jet airliner built for high-speed service, while the Lockheed Constellation was a four-engine piston airliner from the earlier long-range era.
Both were operating scheduled passenger flights into New York, one from Chicago and one from Columbus. In busy terminal airspace, safe separation depended on crews staying within assigned clearances and controllers keeping aircraft apart.
This accident became one of the deadliest airline collisions of its time, and it sat within a broader period when commercial aviation was adapting procedures and control systems to the higher speeds of jet traffic.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened in the 1960 New York midair collision?
United Air Lines Flight 826 and Trans World Airlines Flight 266 collided over Staten Island at 5,000 feet. The TWA Constellation crashed on Staten Island and the United DC-8 crashed in Brooklyn after the crew tried to reach La Guardia.
How many people died in the United and TWA collision over New York?
All 128 people aboard the two aircraft died, and 6 people on the ground were also killed. The total included 44 aboard the TWA Constellation and 84 aboard the United DC-8.
Where did the two aircraft crash after the collision?
The Lockheed Constellation crashed at Miller Army Air Field on Staten Island. The Douglas DC-8 continued briefly, then crashed into the streets of Brooklyn.
What caused the 1960 United and TWA midair collision?
The stated cause was a midair collision. Investigators found that the United crew had exceeded its clearance limits and assigned airspace, and one of the DC-8's VOR receivers was not functioning and had not been reported to air traffic control.
Related accidents
- 128 killed
No fatalities
1 killed
9 killed
6 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.