Fatal accident · Brazil
Air France Airbus A330 crash in the mid-Atlantic on Rio to Paris flight 447
Air France Flight 447, an Airbus A330-203 registered F-GZCP, crashed into the Atlantic Ocean near the TASIL waypoint in the early hours of 1 June 2009 on a flight from Rio de Janeiro to Paris. All 228 people on board died. France's BEA investigated and published its final report in July 2012.
This is one of 73 Air France fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 2009.
What happened to AF447 over the Atlantic
Air France Flight 447 left Rio de Janeiro/Galeão on 31 May 2009 bound for Paris-Charles de Gaulle. The Airbus A330-203 was flying the INTOL, SALPU, ORARO route at flight level 350 when it approached areas of convective cloud associated with the Intertropical Convergence Zone.
At about 02:10 UTC the aircraft sent an automatic position report and several ACARS maintenance messages. The BEA's recorded sequence of flight-data events runs to 02:14:28 UTC. The aircraft then crashed into the ocean. The official material does not give a separate local clock time for impact.
The position is often quoted as about 570 miles northeast of Natal, Brazil. That matches the general area, but the BEA identifies the site by reference to the TASIL waypoint, in the North Atlantic. The aircraft was in cruise when contact was lost, and no distress call is described in the material available.
Storm cloud on the route
The route of the Air France A330 crossed the Intertropical Convergence Zone, where clusters of cumulonimbus cloud were present. The BEA's interim findings described forecast embedded cumulonimbus areas reaching from below FL250 to about FL450. No clear-air turbulence was forecast along the route.
The official material also indicates that strong convective weather was near the aircraft when it disappeared. For wider context, see weather-related crashes.
228 people on board, no survivors
Flight 447 carried 216 passengers and 12 crew, 228 people in total. No one survived. No deaths on the ground were reported in the official accident record.
French and Brazilian naval forces began recovering wreckage and bodies from the Atlantic on 6 June 2009, five days after the aircraft disappeared.
What the BEA found
France's Bureau of Enquiry and Analysis for Civil Aviation Safety (BEA) led the investigation into the loss of the Air France A330. It published interim reports while the work was under way and issued its final report in July 2012. The investigation is closed. Court and regulatory proceedings are separate from the technical safety investigation.
The BEA's findings describe a chain of events. Ice obstructed the pitot probes, and the aircraft lost reliable airspeed information. Inappropriate flight-control inputs followed, and the aircraft went into loss of control at high altitude. The final report's complete causal wording is not reproduced here, so it is not quoted as a direct statement.
The sequence of interim and final reports is a good example of how preliminary and final reports differ. For the category of event, see loss of control in flight.
F-GZCP and the three pilots in the cockpit
Air France Flight 447 was flown by F-GZCP, an Airbus A330-203 with two General Electric CF6-80E1 engines. Air France took delivery on 25 February 2005, so the aircraft was about 4 years and 3 months old at the accident. The BEA recorded roughly 18,870 flight hours and 2,644 flight cycles. Earlier repairs are listed in the report, but none is named as a causal factor.
The aircraft carried Thales AA pitot probes. Similar icing events had occurred in the A330 and A340 fleet before the accident, and Air France had started replacing the probes.
Three pilots were on the flight deck at different times. Captain Marc Dubois had about 11,000 flight hours, including about 1,700 on the A330. First Officer David Robert had about 6,547 hours, with about 4,479 on the type. First Officer Pierre-Cédric Bonin had about 2,936 hours, with about 807 on the A330.
The captain left for a rest break at about 02:02 UTC. Bonin was the pilot flying and Robert was the pilot not flying when the airspeed indications became unreliable.
Four and a half minutes from autopilot disconnect to impact
On Air France Flight 447, the BEA's reconstruction runs from the last routine radio call at 01:35:53 UTC to impact at 02:14:28. At about 01:51 the crew discussed the weather ahead as the aircraft neared the Intertropical Convergence Zone.
At 02:10:05 the autopilot and autothrust disconnected. The flight-control system moved from normal law to alternate law after the airspeed measurements became inconsistent. Between 02:10:06 and 02:10:16 the pilots made inputs that raised the pitch, and the aircraft climbed. The stall warning sounded at 02:10:16. The aircraft reached its maximum altitude of about 38,000 feet at 02:10:51 and then began to descend.
It stayed in a stalled condition for the rest of the flight. At 02:12:02 the stall warning stopped for a time because the computed airspeed values were invalid or below the warning logic's threshold, and it sounded again as the parameters changed. The captain returned to the cockpit at 02:13:32. The crew did not identify a sustained stall in the last minute. The aircraft hit the ocean at high vertical speed at 02:14:28.
The aircraft made no distress call. Automatic ACARS messages reported problems with airspeed, autopilot status, flight-control law and cabin pressure.
Finding the wreckage two years later
The search for Air France Flight 447 produced floating wreckage and bodies on 6 June 2009, about five days after the crash. The BEA's first interim report records that emergency alerts went out on the morning of 1 June, after the aircraft missed expected contacts. The French frigate Ventôse recovered about thirty bodies in the surface search.
The main wreckage was not found until April 2011, at a depth of about 3,900 metres. The flight recorders were recovered afterward, and their data supported the final reconstruction. The BEA concluded that survival was impossible given the impact forces.
The long search shaped the BEA's recommendations. Its flight data recovery working group proposed extending underwater locator beacon transmission to 90 days. It also proposed an additional beacon to help locate wreckage early, and a study of mandatory transmission of basic parameters such as position, altitude, speed and heading. The BEA's recommendations also covered search-and-rescue initiation and coordination.
The report also lists 32 nationalities among the 228 people aboard. The BEA points to the manifest in its final report for the breakdown. The general process is described in what happens after a plane crash.
Acquittal in 2023 and what the court did not change
French prosecutors charged both Air France and Airbus with involuntary manslaughter over the loss of Flight 447. At the Paris trial in 2023 the court acquitted both companies. It held that a sufficiently certain causal link between their failings and the deaths had not been proved, while acknowledging shortcomings in their practices.
The judgment did not overturn the BEA's technical findings. The BEA's stated probable cause was the crew's failure to recognise the stickshaker as a sign of an imminent stall, and their failure to apply appropriate procedures to recover control. The report also listed lack of high-altitude manual handling training, weakened task-sharing, no clear display of airspeed inconsistencies, and weak feedback between operators, manufacturers, regulators and training bodies. For how such wording is used, see what probable cause means.
Debate over emphasis continued. In Brazil, public discussion often gave more weight to the sensor weakness and to what Airbus knew about earlier icing events. Civil claims by families ran separately under the Montreal Convention and other applicable law, and amounts varied between families. A memorial stands at Marinha in Brazil, and others were held in France and Brazil.
Earlier pitot probe events on the A330
BEA material on the Airbus A330 records that Airbus had identified 32 events between 12 November 2003 and 1 June 2009 involving possible ice-related obstruction or destruction of pitot probes. Eleven of them were in 2008 and 10 were in the first five months of 2009. These were events, not all accidents, and none of those listed in the material is described as a crash.
The material available documents no earlier accident involving F-GZCP itself. It does not give the aircraft's age or delivery date. A complete list of earlier Air France fatal accidents is also not included, so none is asserted here.
Type histories are collected on the aircraft model accident history page, and the process investigators use to determine cause is described separately.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened to Air France Flight 447?
Air France Flight 447, an Airbus A330-203, crashed into the Atlantic Ocean in the early hours of 1 June 2009 on a Rio de Janeiro to Paris flight. All 228 on board died.
How many people died on Air France Flight 447?
All 228 people on board the Airbus A330 died: 216 passengers and 12 crew. No one on the ground was reported killed.
What caused the Air France 447 crash?
The BEA attributed the accident to loss of reliable airspeed information after ice obstructed the pitot probes, inappropriate flight-control inputs, and loss of control at high altitude.
Who investigated the Air France 447 crash?
France's Bureau of Enquiry and Analysis for Civil Aviation Safety (BEA) investigated the Airbus A330 accident and published its final report in July 2012.
Where did Air France Flight 447 crash?
It crashed in the North Atlantic Ocean near the TASIL waypoint, commonly described as about 570 miles northeast of Natal, Brazil.
What aircraft was Air France Flight 447?
It was an Airbus A330-203 registered F-GZCP, operated by Air France on the Rio de Janeiro to Paris route.
What altitude was AF447 flying at?
The Air France A330 was in cruise at flight level 350 when contact was lost over the Atlantic.
When was the wreckage of Air France 447 found?
Wreckage and bodies began to be recovered on 6 June 2009 by French and Brazilian naval forces.
Related accidents
- 109 killed, 4 on the ground
- 95 killed
- 112 killed
- 130 killed
- 77 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.