Fatal accident · Germany

Bashkirian and DHL mid-air collision near Uberlingen

On July 1, 2002, Bashkirian Airlines Flight 2937 and DHL Flight 611 collided over Uberlingen, Germany. The Tupolev Tu-154M and Boeing 757 freighter carried 71 people in total, and all 71 died. The cause was air traffic control error.

This is one of 1 Bashkirian Airlines fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 2002.

Flight 2937 and Flight 611 collided at cruise altitude

Flight 2937 and Flight 611 collided over southern Germany at 35,400 feet. The aircraft were a Bashkirian Airlines Tupolev Tu-154M carrying passengers and a DHL Worldwide Express Boeing 757 freighter on a cargo flight. There were 71 people aboard the two aircraft combined, and none survived.

The collision happened near Uberlingen. Debris fell across an area about 20 miles wide. Among the 69 people aboard the Tupolev were 52 children traveling on a beach holiday. No one on the ground was killed.

The crash involved two transport aircraft on separate international routes, one flying from Moscow to Barcelona with a stop at Munich, the other flying from Bahrain toward Brussels. Mid-air collisions between airliners are rare because separation by air traffic control and onboard collision warning systems are both meant to prevent exactly this situation.

The Tupolev crew received two different commands

Flight 2937 received conflicting instructions in the final moments before impact. The Tupolev's traffic collision avoidance system, TCAS, ordered the crew to climb. One second later, a Swiss air traffic controller instructed the Tupolev pilots to descend.

The Tupolev crew did not respond at once to the order from the controller, so he repeated the descent instruction 14 seconds later. Thirty seconds after that, the two aircraft collided. During the same sequence, the Boeing's TCAS instructed its crew to descend.

That left the Tupolev crew with a direct conflict between cockpit equipment and ground control. Russian aviation officials said the pilot correctly gave precedence to the controller's instruction. Western aviation specialists said pilots were trained to follow the TCAS command instead. TCAS is designed to issue coordinated escape directions to both aircraft, one climbing and the other descending, so that each crew reacts to the same traffic picture in complementary ways. More on that process is covered in how investigators determine the cause.

Skyguide's control position was degraded that night

Uberlingen airspace was being handled by a Swiss controller working alone when the conflict developed. His colleague was on a break, and that single-person operation was accepted policy at Skyguide, the Swiss air navigation company.

The controller was also occupied with another aircraft. At the same time, maintenance work on the computer system reduced the information available to him, including conflict alert warnings. He had no way to know that the Tupolev crew was receiving a contradictory TCAS command unless the pilots told him.

Those conditions matter because they reduced both staffing and technical backup at the same moment a fast-developing conflict needed immediate attention. Air traffic control error was identified as the cause. This crash is one of several cases grouped under other accidents with the same cause.

The collision led to a later killing on the ground

Uberlingen was followed by another violent event more than a year later. Peter Nielsen, the Swiss air traffic controller involved that night, was stabbed to death by a Russian man who had lost his wife and two children in the collision.

That later homicide was separate from the crash itself, but it became part of the public history of the accident. The aviation side of the event centered on how crews and controllers should act when TCAS and air traffic control disagree. In general, later safety practice in commercial flying put clear priority on following TCAS resolution advisories in those moments so that both aircraft respond in a coordinated way.

Questions people ask about this accident

What happened in the Uberlingen mid-air collision?

Bashkirian Airlines Flight 2937 and DHL Flight 611 collided over Uberlingen, Germany, at 35,400 feet on July 1, 2002. All 71 people aboard the Tupolev Tu-154M and Boeing 757 died.

What caused the 2002 Uberlingen crash?

The cause was air traffic control error. The Tupolev crew also received conflicting instructions, with TCAS telling them to climb while the Swiss controller told them to descend.

How many children died on Bashkirian Airlines Flight 2937?

Fifty-two children on a beach holiday were among the 69 people aboard the Tupolev. Everyone on that aircraft died.

Who was the controller in the Uberlingen collision?

The controller involved was Peter Nielsen. More than a year after the crash, he was stabbed to death by a Russian man who had lost family members in the accident.

  1. Pulkovo Tu-154 crashed after storm deviation near Donetsk

    Near Donetsk, Ukraine · Tupolev Tu-154M · Pulkovo Airlines · RA-85185

    170 killed
  2. Sibir Airlines Flight 1812 shot down over the Black Sea

    110 miles SW of Sochi, Russia · Tupolev Tu-154M · Sibir Airlines · RA-85693

    78 killed
  3. Vladivostokavia Flight 352 crashed near Irkutsk

    Near Irkutsk, Russia · Tupolev TU-154M · Vladivostokavia · RA-85845

    145 killed
  4. Cubana de Aviacion Flight 389 overran at Quito

    Quito, Ecuador · Tupolev TU-154M · Cubana de Aviacion · CU-T1264

    70 killed, 10 on the ground
  5. Vnokovo Airlines Flight 2801 hit Operafjellet near Longyearbyen

    Near Longyearbyen, Norway · Tupolev TU-154M · Vnokovo Airlines · RA-85621

    141 killed

Correct this page or send a photo

Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.

By sending a photo you confirm you took it and allow Air Crash DB to publish it with your credit. We keep your message and, if you give them, your name and email, until the correction is handled. See the privacy policy.