Plane crashes caused by air traffic control errors

Accidents where an instruction from a controller, or a missing one, was the main cause. Standard phraseology and readback rules exist to close exactly these gaps.

33fatal accidents on record
1937earliest
2004most recent
234deaths in the worst

For the background and the numbers, read the guide: Runway incursion

All 33, by death toll

  1. Garuda Indonesia Airlines Flight 152 crash at Buah Nabar

    Buah Nabar, Indonesia · Airbus A300-B4-200 · Garuda Indonesia Airlines · PK-GAI

    234 killed
  2. Aeroflot Flight 7880/7628 crash near Volgograd

    Near Volgograd, Russia · Tupolev TU-134A / Tupolev Tu-134A · Aeroflot / Aeroflot · 65735/65816

    178 killed
  3. Aeroflot Flight 3352 crash near Omsk

    Near Omsk, Russia · Tupolev TU-154B · Aeroflot · CCCP-85243

    174 killed, 4 on the ground
  4. Inex Adria Aviopromet Flight 550/476 crash near Gaj

    Near Gaj, Hrvatska, Yugoslavia · McDonnell Douglas DC-9-31 / Trident 3B · Inex Adria Aviopromet / British Airways · YU-AJR/G-AWZT

    176 killed
  5. Venezolana Internacional de Aviacion Flight 742 crash at Maracaibo

    Maracaibo, Zulia, Venezuela · McDonnell Douglas DC-9-32 · Venezolana Internacional de Aviacion · YV-C-AVD

    84 killed, 71 on the ground
  6. Aviation Development Corporation Flight 086 crash at Lagos

    Lagos, Nigeria · Boeing B-727-231 · Aviation Development Corporation · 5N-BBF

    143 killed
  7. SAM Colombia Flight 501 crash near Medellin

    Near Medellin, Colombia · Boeing B-727-46 · SAM Colombia · HK-2422X

    132 killed
  8. Scandinavian Airlines (SAS) Flight 686 / - crash at Milan

    Milan, Italy · MD-87 / Cessna 525A Citation II · Scandinavian Airlines (SAS) / Private · SE-DMA / D-IEVX

    114 killed, 4 on the ground
  9. Iberia Airlines Flight 350/134 crash near Madrid

    Near Madrid, Spain · Boeing B-727-200 / DC9-32 · Iberia Airlines / Aviaco · EC-CFJ/EC-CGS

    93 killed
  10. Aeroflot Antonov AN-10A crash near Adler

    Near Adler, Russia · Antonov AN-10A · Aeroflot · CCCP11186

    81 killed
  11. Bashkirian Airlines Flight 2937 / 611 crash at Uberlingen

    Uberlingen, Germany · Tupolev TU-154M / Boeing B-757-23APF · Bashkirian Airlines / DHL Worldwide Express · RA85816/A9C-DHL

    71 killed
  12. Lineas Aereas de Espana/Spantax SA Transportes Flight 504/400 crash near Nantes

    Near Nantes, France · MD Douglas DC-9-32/Convair CV-990A · Lineas Aereas de Espana/Spantax SA Transportes · EC-BII/EC-BJC

    68 killed
  13. Aeroflot Flight 7957 /31 crash off Adler

    Off Adler, Russia · Antonov AN-24 / Yakovlev Yak-40 · Aeroflot / Aeroflot · CCCP46518/87772

    64 killed
  14. Aeroflot Flight E-15 crash near Batumi

    Near Batumi, Georgia, USSR · Yakovlev YAK-40 · Aeroflot · CCCP-87475

    40 killed
  15. Balkan Bulgarian Airlines Ilyushin IL-14P crash near Plovdiv

    Near Plovdiv, Bulgaria · Ilyushin IL-14P · Balkan Bulgarian Airlines · LZ-ILA

    35 killed
  16. USAir Flight 1493/5569 crash at LAX

    LAX, Los Angeles, California · Boeing B-737-300 / Swearingen SA-227AC · USAir / Skywest Airlines · N388US/N683AV

    34 killed
  17. Aeroflot Flight 10 crash near Birobidzhan

    Near Birobidzhan, Russia · Ilyushin IL-12 · Aeroflot · CCCP-L1309

    27 killed
  18. Aeroflot Flight 376 crash at Skvoritsy

    Skvoritsy, Russia · Ilyushin IL-12 · Aeroflot · L1328

    21 killed
  19. Prinair de Havilland DH-114 Heron 2D crash at San Juan

    San Juan, Puerto Rico · de Havilland DH-114 Heron 2D · Prinair · N563PR

    19 killed
  20. Aeroflot Flight 7950 crash at Kharkov

    Kharkov, Ukraine, USSR · Antonov AN-24 · Aeroflot · CCCP-46349

    19 killed
  21. Aviaco de Havilland DH-114 Heron 2D crash off Castell de Fels

    Off Castell de Fels, Spain · de Havilland DH-114 Heron 2D · Aviaco · EC-ANJ

    16 killed
  22. Private North American B-25 Mitchell crash at Lake Erie off Huron

    Lake Erie off Huron, Ohio · North American B-25 Mitchell · Private · N3443G

    16 killed
  23. U.S. Navy / NASA Lockheed P-3C / Convair CV-990-30A-5 crash at Moffett AFB

    Moffett AFB, California · Lockheed P-3C / Convair CV-990-30A-5 · U.S. Navy / NASA · 157332/N711NA

    16 killed
  24. U.S. Air Force Lockheed C-141A (L.300) crash near Quilcene

    Near Quilcene, Washington · Lockheed C-141A (L.300) · U.S. Air Force · 64-0641

    16 killed
  25. Aeroflot Antonov An-2 / Antonov An-12 crash at Irkutsk

    Irkutsk, Russia · Antonov An-2 / Antonov An-12 · Aeroflot · 49342/12985

    13 killed
  26. Aeroflot / Aeroflot Let 410UVP Turbojet / Tupolev TU-134V crash at Sukhumi

    Sukhumi, Georgia, USSR · Let 410UVP Turbojet / Tupolev TU-134V · Aeroflot / Aeroflot · 67191 / 65836

    11 killed
  27. Balkan Bulgarian Airlines Antonov An-14 crash at Rila mountain

    Rila mountain, Bulgaria · Antonov An-14 · Balkan Bulgarian Airlines · LZ-7005

    9 killed
  28. Aeroflot Antonov An-26 crash near Almaty

    Near Almaty, Kazakhstan · Antonov An-26 · Aeroflot · CCCP-26007

    9 killed
  29. Aeroflot Douglas C-47 crash at Khabarovsk

    Khabarovsk, Russia · Douglas C-47 · Aeroflot · CCCP-L1073

    8 killed
  30. Wasa Wings Embraer 110P1 Bandeirante crash at Ilmajoki

    Ilmajoki, Finland · Embraer 110P1 Bandeirante · Wasa Wings · OH-EBA

    6 killed
  31. Med Flight Air Ambulance - Private Learjet 35A crash at San Diego

    San Diego, California · Learjet 35A · Med Flight Air Ambulance - Private · N30DK

    5 killed
  32. Eastern Air Lines Flight 7 crash at Daytona Beach

    Daytona Beach, Florida · Douglas DC-2 · Eastern Air Lines · NC-13739

    4 killed
  33. Trans Canada Air Lines Vickers 757 Viscount crash at Bagotville

    Bagotville, Quebec, Canada · Vickers 757 Viscount · Trans Canada Air Lines · CF-THA

    2 killed

Each accident is filed under one main cause, taken from the accident summary. Most accidents have several contributing factors, and for older records the cause is sometimes uncertain. See how investigators find the cause.

Questions

How many plane crashes were caused by air traffic control errors?

The Air Crash DB database has 33 fatal accidents with air traffic control errors as the main cause, between 1937 and 2004. Causes are assigned from the accident summary, so accidents with no stated cause are not counted.

What was the deadliest?

The deadliest was Garuda Indonesia Airlines Flight 152 crash at Buah Nabar on September 26, 1997 at Buah Nabar, Indonesia, with 234 deaths.

All causes