Fatal accident · France
Spantax DC-9 and Convair 990 collided near Nantes
On March 5, 1973, Spantax flights 504 and 400, a DC-9-32 and a Convair CV-990A, collided near Nantes, France. There were 182 people aboard the two aircraft and 68 died. The cause was air traffic control error.
This is one of 1 Lineas Aereas de Espana/Spantax SA Transportes fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1973.
Flight 504 and Flight 400 met in cloud near Nantes
Flight 504 and Flight 400 were both heading from Palma de Mallorca to London when they came together in midair near Nantes. The operator was Lineas Aereas de Espana, Spantax SA Transportes. The aircraft were a McDonnell Douglas DC-9-32, registered EC-BII, and a Convair CV-990A, registered EC-BJC.
The two aircraft were flying at the same altitude, but on different airways. While the Convair was in overcast, it collided with the DC-9. Midair collisions in airline service were rare, but they were one of the reasons airways, altitude assignments, and handoffs between control sectors had to be followed exactly.
A missed handoff and an unauthorized turn preceded the collision
The Convair CV-990A reached an air traffic control sector boundary when its crew could barely hear a Marina controller instruct them to contact Menhir control. The pilot understood that handoff differently and believed contact with Menhir should happen when passing the Nantes VOR.
The Convair crew then tried twice to request permission for a 360-degree turn so they could delay reaching the VOR. They received no answer from Marina control. The crew began the turn without clearance, and during that maneuver the Convair struck the DC-9.
Air traffic control error was given as the cause. This accident is listed with other accidents with the same cause, and it also shows how controllers and investigators separate communication failures from crew actions when they determine causes in complex events. Air accident inquiries usually set that out in detail in the same way described in how investigators determine the cause.
The Convair landed at Cognac, the DC-9 fell out of control
The Convair lost an outboard section of its left wing in the collision, but its crew kept the aircraft flyable long enough to carry out an emergency landing at Cognac-Chateaubernard Air Base. Damage of that kind could sharply change lift and roll control, so keeping the aircraft under control depended on careful handling and enough remaining structure.
The DC-9 lost control after the impact and crashed. All 68 deaths were on that aircraft. There were no fatalities on the ground.
Military controllers were working during a civilian strike
France was using military personnel in the air traffic control system that day because civilian controllers were on strike. That operating setup formed part of the circumstances around the handoff between Marina and Menhir sectors.
The accident involved 182 people aboard the two aircraft. Why the communication and separation process broke down at that point was addressed as an air traffic control failure, with the crew's mistaken understanding of the handoff and the unapproved turn also part of the sequence that led to the collision.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened in the 1973 Nantes midair collision?
Spantax flights 504 and 400, a DC-9-32 and a Convair CV-990A, collided near Nantes, France, on March 5, 1973, while both were en route from Palma de Mallorca to London.
How many people died in the Spantax Nantes collision?
There were 68 fatalities among the 182 people aboard the two aircraft. There were no deaths on the ground.
Did either aircraft survive the collision near Nantes?
Yes. The Convair CV-990A lost an outboard portion of its left wing but made an emergency landing at Cognac-Chateaubernard Air Base. The DC-9 lost control and crashed.
What caused the Spantax DC-9 and Convair 990 collision?
The cause was air traffic control error. Before the collision, the Convair crew had difficulty hearing a handoff instruction, misunderstood when to contact the next control sector, and began a 360-degree turn without clearance after getting no reply.
Related accidents
- 67 killed, 15 on the ground
- 83 killed
- 150 killed
- 109 killed, 4 on the ground
- 87 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.