Fatal accident · Canada
Swissair MD-11 crash off Peggy's Cove, Nova Scotia, kills all 229
Swissair Flight 111, a McDonnell Douglas MD-11 registered HB-IWF, crashed into the Atlantic Ocean about 5 nautical miles southwest of Peggy's Cove, Nova Scotia, on 2 September 1998. All 229 people aboard, 215 passengers and 14 crew, died. Canada's Transportation Safety Board investigated and found an in-flight fire above the cockpit ceiling.
This is one of 11 Swissair fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1998.
A smell in the cockpit about 52 minutes after departure
Swissair Flight 111 left John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York at 21:18 Atlantic daylight time on 2 September 1998, bound for Geneva. The aircraft was a McDonnell Douglas MD-11, registration HB-IWF, with 215 passengers and 14 crew aboard. It was a scheduled service, flown as SR 111.
At about 22:10:38 the pilots noticed an unusual odor in the cockpit. They reported smoke or fumes and began assessing the problem. The crew first planned to divert to Boston, then selected Halifax instead.
They declared an emergency and began descending toward Halifax. The aircraft was roughly 40 nautical miles from the airport when the emergency developed, according to the official investigation summary.
The fire spread in the area above the cockpit ceiling. The crew went on to lose essential systems and control of the aircraft.
Seismic recorders placed the impact with the water at about 22:31:18, which is about 01:31:18 UTC on 3 September. The MD-11 was destroyed in the Atlantic about 5 nautical miles southwest of Peggy's Cove, near the entrance to St. Margaret's Bay. Nobody survived. No one on the ground was reported hurt.
The MD-11 and Swissair's New York to Geneva service
HB-IWF was a McDonnell Douglas MD-11 built in 1991, which made it about seven years old when it crashed off Nova Scotia. Swissair flew it on the New York to Geneva route as flight SR 111.
The aircraft was in the cruise phase when the odor was first noticed. It then descended on a diversion to Halifax, and it crashed during that emergency descent and approach.
A reliable, authoritative list of earlier Swissair or MD-11 accidents was not confirmed in the material available, so none is stated here. For wider context, see accident history by aircraft model and airline safety records.
The 229 people on board
All 229 people aboard the Swissair MD-11 died: 215 passengers and 14 crew members. There were no survivors, and no deaths or injuries were reported on the ground.
The aircraft broke up on striking the water, and the wreckage lay in the sea off Peggy's Cove. The impact forces destroyed the aircraft, according to the official investigation summary.
What the Transportation Safety Board of Canada concluded
Canada's Transportation Safety Board (TSB) investigated the Swissair Flight 111 crash under report A98H0003. The investigation is closed. The TSB issued its final report in 2003.
The TSB concluded that an in-flight fire above the cockpit ceiling caused extensive damage to aircraft systems and ultimately led to loss of control.
It identified an electrical arcing event involving wiring associated with the in-flight entertainment system as likely related to how the fire started. It also found that flammable materials in the ceiling-area construction let the fire spread beyond the crew's ability to control it.
The way investigators reach findings like these is covered in how investigators determine the cause. The difference between interim and final findings is explained in preliminary vs final accident report.
HB-IWF had 36,000 flight hours and an earlier wingtip repair
HB-IWF, the McDonnell Douglas MD-11 flown as Swissair Flight 111, had about 36,000 flight hours and about 6,400 flight cycles when it crashed off Peggy's Cove, according to the Transportation Safety Board of Canada (TSB) report. In 1992 its right wingtip was damaged in a ground collision at Newark. The damage was repaired and the aircraft returned to service.
The TSB report also documents maintenance work and modifications tied to the in-flight entertainment system. The FAA's accident summary says that system was installed under an FAA-approved supplemental type certificate. Investigators concluded that an arcing event involving wiring associated with it was likely connected with the start of the fire.
Two pilots were on the flight deck of the MD-11. The captain had about 10,800 hours of total flying time, including about 900 hours on the MD-11. The first officer had about 4,800 hours, including about 230 on the type. The TSB report states that both pilots were properly licensed, medically fit and qualified for the flight. The first officer was the pilot flying, and the captain worked through the checklist.
Neither pilot was found responsible for causing the accident. The report describes conditions on the flight deck as extreme and deteriorating rapidly.
From the Pan Pan call to impact: the last 13 minutes of SR 111
Swissair Flight 111 was in contact with Moncton Area Control Centre for most of the emergency, and the TSB timeline shows how quickly it ended. Times here are UTC. One timeline lists the first odor at 00:48 UTC, but this page keeps the 22:10:38 Atlantic daylight time figure given above.
- 01:10: the crew asked Moncton to divert to Halifax. The MD-11 was about 56 nautical miles southwest of the airport.
- 01:18: the crew declared Pan Pan and reported smoke in the cockpit. Moncton cleared the aircraft toward Halifax and gave vectors.
- 01:23: airspeed was reducing through about 306 knots. The first officer asked whether to slow further, and the captain said he was in the checklist and the first officer should fly as he saw fit.
- 01:24:38 to 01:24:42: the cockpit voice recorder captured altitude-alert tones, with the selector at 10,000 feet. The captain then declared an emergency.
- 01:25 to 01:26: electrical and flight-management functions began to fail.
Both primary recorders stopped about six minutes before impact when electrical power was lost. The aircraft struck the water at about 01:31, roughly five and a half minutes after its final emergency communications, according to the official accident-summary material. The TSB built its chronology from recorders, ATC tapes, radar and ACARS data.
The TSB never found the wire that started the fire
In its final report on Swissair Flight 111, the TSB did not identify a single wire, component or circuit as the ignition source. It named electrical arcing as the most likely start but could not establish the exact device. The entertainment system was treated as a possible contributor, not a proven origin. Several contributing factors were listed, and the probable cause wording rested on the fire's spread rather than its start.
- Thermal-acoustic insulation covered with metallized polyethylene terephthalate (MPET) could ignite and spread fire.
- Certification flammability tests did not represent real conditions.
- There was no effective fire detection or suppression above the cockpit ceiling.
- The loss of power to the recorders limited reconstruction of the final minutes.
The TSB issued 23 recommendations, 14 during the investigation and nine with the final report. They covered flammability testing, circuit-breaker resetting, recorder power and data capture, cockpit image recording, and a review of in-flight firefighting as a system.
In the United States, the FAA issued an MD-11 airworthiness directive in early 1999 requiring inspections for wiring faults that could cause arcing, smoke or fire. It later ordered operators of affected MD-80, MD-88, MD-90, DC-10 and MD-11 aircraft to replace metalized Mylar insulation blankets.
Settlements, a rejected punitive claim and two memorials
Litigation over the Swissair MD-11 crash ended mostly in negotiated settlements. In September 1999 Swissair, Delta Air Lines and Boeing, the successor to McDonnell Douglas, agreed to share liability and offered families compensation. Some plaintiffs rejected that framework and sued Swissair and DuPont, the supplier associated with the Mylar insulation covering.
A U.S. federal court rejected claims for punitive damages in February 2002. One reported group of plaintiffs received more than US$13 million in total. No single figure for all families has been made public, and confidentiality limited the record. No criminal prosecution followed. For how such cases usually proceed, see what happens after a plane crash.
Two memorials stand near Peggy's Cove. The Swissair Flight 111 Memorial at Bayswater overlooks St. Margarets Bay and lists the names of the 229 people who died. A second memorial near Whalesback is closer to the crash site and represents the aircraft's flight path and its distance from the wreckage area.
The cited official material does not show the TSB investigation being formally reopened. Later work was regulatory, mainly the FAA's inspection and replacement orders for insulation and wiring.
Weather and details not confirmed
The sources used for this account of the Swissair MD-11 crash do not give a full official weather observation for the time of impact. The accident happened at night over the Atlantic. Visibility, cloud, wind and turbulence are not stated here for that reason.
The TSB did not attribute the crash to weather. For that category of accident, see weather-related crashes. The TSB finding falls closer to mechanical failure crashes, since it centred on a fire and damaged aircraft systems.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened to Swissair Flight 111?
Swissair Flight 111, an MD-11, crashed into the Atlantic Ocean off Peggy's Cove, Nova Scotia, on 2 September 1998 after a fire broke out above the cockpit ceiling. All 229 people aboard died.
How many people died on Swissair Flight 111?
All 229 people aboard the Swissair MD-11 died, 215 passengers and 14 crew. There were no survivors and no ground fatalities.
Where did Swissair Flight 111 crash?
It crashed in the Atlantic Ocean about 5 nautical miles southwest of Peggy's Cove, Nova Scotia, near the entrance to St. Margaret's Bay.
What caused the Swissair Flight 111 crash?
Canada's Transportation Safety Board found an in-flight fire above the cockpit ceiling that damaged aircraft systems and led to loss of control. Arcing in wiring associated with the in-flight entertainment system was identified as likely related to the fire's start.
Where was Swissair Flight 111 flying to?
The MD-11 was flying from John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York to Geneva, Switzerland.
Why was Swissair Flight 111 diverting to Halifax?
The crew noticed an odor and reported smoke or fumes about 52 minutes after takeoff. They first considered Boston, then chose Halifax and declared an emergency.
What time did Swissair Flight 111 crash?
Seismic recorders placed the impact at about 22:31:18 Atlantic daylight time on 2 September 1998.
Who investigated the Swissair Flight 111 crash?
Canada's Transportation Safety Board investigated under report A98H0003 and issued its final report in 2003.
Related accidents
- 256 killed
- 109 killed
- 118 killed
- 80 killed
3 killed, 12 on the ground
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.