Fatal accident · United States

American Airlines DC-10 crash on takeoff at Chicago O'Hare

American Airlines Flight 191, a McDonnell Douglas DC-10-10 bound for Los Angeles, crashed during takeoff from Chicago O'Hare International Airport on May 25, 1979. All 271 people on board and two people on the ground died. The NTSB investigated and traced the crash to maintenance-induced damage that let the left engine separate.

This is one of 35 American Airlines fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1979.

The left engine tore away during rotation

American Airlines Flight 191 crashed at about 3:04 p.m. Central Daylight Time on May 25, 1979. It was departing Runway 32R at Chicago O'Hare International Airport for Los Angeles. Weather was clear, with 15 miles of visibility.

As the McDonnell Douglas DC-10-10 rotated, the No. 1 (left) engine and its pylon separated from the wing. The engine travelled over the wing and fell onto the runway. The aircraft kept climbing for a short time.

The separation damaged hydraulic lines and the outboard leading-edge slats on the left wing retracted without a command. That left the left wing stalling at a higher speed than the right. The aircraft rolled left and hit an open field about 4,600 feet northwest of the departure end of the runway, just short of a trailer park. It came down inverted.

271 on board, 273 dead

The DC-10 was carrying 258 passengers and 13 crew members, 271 people in all. Nobody on board survived. Two people on the ground also died, which brings the total to 273.

The sources reviewed do not give a verified count of people injured on the ground.

Why the crew had little warning

On the DC-10, N110AA, the loss of hydraulic pressure also affected the stall-warning and slat-disagreement indications, according to the FAA. The crew was therefore without the warnings that would normally have flagged the slat problem. The result was the asymmetric stall that ended in the roll.

This kind of event is classed as loss of control in flight, though here the trigger was a mechanical failure that began with maintenance.

What the NTSB found

The National Transportation Safety Board investigated the Flight 191 crash under number DCA79AA017 and published Aircraft Accident Report AAR-79-17. Its probable cause was the asymmetric stall and the ensuing roll that followed the uncommanded retraction of the left-wing outboard slats and the loss of the related warning indications.

The NTSB attributed the engine and pylon separation to maintenance-induced structural damage caused by improper maintenance procedures. For more on how such findings are reached, see what probable cause means.

The DC-10 type certificate was revoked for 37 days

After the Chicago crash, the FAA administrator revoked the DC-10 type certificate for 37 days while the investigation went on. The investigation is closed and the NTSB report is public.

The aircraft's age at the time is not confirmed in the sources reviewed, so it is left out here.

N110AA had flown about 19,871 hours and came out of an engine change at Tulsa

The McDonnell Douglas DC-10-10 that flew as American Airlines Flight 191, registration N110AA, was delivered new to American in 1972. It had been in service about seven years when it crashed at Chicago O'Hare, and the NTSB recorded its total time as approximately 19,871 flight hours.

The work that doomed it had been done earlier, during an engine change at American's maintenance facility in Tulsa. Mechanics removed the No. 1 engine and its pylon together, using a forklift-based procedure, instead of separating the engine from the pylon first. That method damaged the structure that supports the pylon. Later inspections did not find the damage.

The aircraft therefore left Tulsa with a weakened pylon and flew in that condition until the takeoff roll on Runway 32R. When the structure failed, the engine and pylon came off the left wing together. The separation damaged hydraulic, electrical and leading-edge-slat systems, according to the NTSB report and the NTSB investigation page.

The manufacturer's recommended procedure called for the engine to be separated from the pylon before the pylon was taken off the wing. The NTSB concluded that the shortcut created a serious chance of structural damage. It was faster than the approved method, but it could pass damaging loads into the pylon if the assembly was misaligned or poorly supported. Details of the mechanical failures behind other crashes show how rarely a single maintenance step is the origin.

Three flight officers with about 46,000 hours between them

American Airlines Flight 191 had a three-person cockpit crew, and the NTSB report gives the age and experience of each.

  • Captain Walter Lux: 53 years old, with about 22,000 hours of total flight time and about 3,000 hours on the DC-10.
  • First Officer James Dillard: 49 years old, with about 9,000 hours in total and about 1,000 on the DC-10.
  • Flight Engineer Alfred Udovich: 56 years old, with about 15,000 hours in total and about 3,000 on the DC-10.

Together that is roughly 46,000 hours. The Chicago Tribune's later accounts of the NTSB findings repeat these figures.

The NTSB did not treat the crew's actions as the primary cause. Its fifth contributing factor was that the prescribed operational procedures were intolerant of this unique emergency. The standard procedure for an engine failure on takeoff pointed the pilots to an engine-out target speed. With the slats retracted on the damaged left wing, that speed was not enough to prevent an asymmetric stall. The report treated the procedure as the weak point, not the pilots' handling of it.

The crew also had no reliable cockpit indication of how much had been lost. The stall-warning and slat-disagreement systems were affected by the same damage, as the page's earlier section on warnings explains.

About 31 seconds from liftoff to the field near Des Plaines

The NTSB reconstructed the last minutes of American Airlines Flight 191 from the flight data recorder, air traffic control records, the cockpit voice recorder and witness accounts. Some events are timed to the second and others are approximate.

  • About 2:50 p.m.: the DC-10 began taxiing for Runway 32R.
  • About 3:02 p.m.: it was cleared for takeoff.
  • About 3:02:46 p.m.: the takeoff roll began.
  • At about 158 knots: the aircraft reached the decision speed, V1. The crew continued the takeoff.
  • At about 172 knots: the DC-10 became airborne, without the left engine and pylon.

Soon after liftoff the aircraft began to roll left. The pilots flew the prescribed engine-failure procedure. The DC-10 reached only about 325 feet above the ground.

About 31 seconds after it left the runway, the aircraft rolled sharply left, descended and hit an open field near a trailer park in Des Plaines, Illinois. The impact came at approximately 3:04 p.m.

The cockpit voice recorder captured a crew remark equivalent to "we've lost an engine." The crew did not report that the engine and pylon had come off, and the NTSB noted that they apparently could not see this from the cockpit. Published summaries paraphrase these exchanges, and exact wording is in the transcript in AAR-79-17.

Five contributing factors and a dispute over responsibility

The NTSB issued its report on American Airlines Flight 191 on December 21, 1979, as AAR-79-17. Beyond the probable cause already described on this page, it listed five contributing factors:

  • the vulnerability of the pylon attachment design to maintenance damage;
  • the vulnerability of the leading-edge slat system to damage that produced asymmetry;
  • deficiencies in FAA surveillance and reporting systems, which failed to detect and prevent improper maintenance procedures;
  • deficiencies in practices and communications among operators, the manufacturer and the FAA, which failed to determine and pass on the particulars of earlier maintenance damage;
  • the intolerance of prescribed operational procedures to this emergency.

The dispute was over responsibility, not over what physically happened. McDonnell Douglas disputed parts of how the NTSB allocated blame, in particular how far the aircraft's design and its maintenance instructions should count as causal. The final report gave causal weight both to the improper maintenance and to the design vulnerabilities in the pylon and slat system.

The NTSB also criticized the FAA and the industry for not sharing information about earlier incidents of maintenance damage. No foreign investigation put forward a different mechanism. The NTSB's current accident page still states the original probable cause, and no later inquiry overturning it has been identified. For how such findings are reached, see how investigators determine the cause.

Earlier DC-10 accidents

American Airlines DC-10s had been involved in earlier accidents. On June 12, 1972, American Airlines Flight 96 lost its aft bulk cargo door in flight near Windsor, Ontario. The NTSB found improper engagement of the door-latching mechanism. The aircraft was substantially damaged, but the event was not fatal.

On November 3, 1973, a National Airlines DC-10 suffered a fan assembly disintegration on the No. 3 engine in cruise at 39,000 feet. Neither event has been shown to be a precursor to the pylon failure on Flight 191. For wider context, see accident history by aircraft model.

Questions people ask about this accident

What happened to American Airlines Flight 191?

The McDonnell Douglas DC-10-10 lost its left engine and pylon during takeoff from Chicago O'Hare on May 25, 1979. It then rolled left and crashed in a field northwest of Runway 32R.

How many people died in the American Airlines Flight 191 crash?

All 271 people aboard died, and two people on the ground were also killed, for a total of 273.

What caused the Flight 191 crash at O'Hare?

The NTSB said the engine and pylon separated because of maintenance-induced damage from improper maintenance procedures. The probable cause was the asymmetric stall and roll after the left slats retracted.

Where did American Airlines Flight 191 crash?

It crashed in an open field about 4,600 feet northwest of the end of Runway 32R at Chicago O'Hare International Airport, Illinois.

Did anyone survive American Airlines Flight 191?

No. All 258 passengers and 13 crew members on the DC-10 died.

Where was Flight 191 going?

American Airlines Flight 191 was scheduled to fly from Chicago O'Hare to Los Angeles International Airport.

Who investigated the Chicago DC-10 crash?

The National Transportation Safety Board investigated under number DCA79AA017 and published report AAR-79-17.

Was the DC-10 grounded after Flight 191?

The FAA administrator revoked the DC-10 type certificate for 37 days while the investigation of the Chicago crash proceeded.

  1. American Airlines Airbus A300 crash in Belle Harbor, Queens, after JFK takeoff

    Belle Harbor, Queens, New York · Airbus A300-605R · American Airlines · N14053

    260 killed, 5 on the ground
  2. American Airlines Flight 11 Boeing 767 hijacked and flown into World Trade Center

    New York City, New York · Boeing 767-223ER · American Airlines · N334AA

    92 killed
  3. American Airlines Flight 77 Boeing 757 hijacked and flown into the Pentagon

    Arlington, Virginia · Boeing 757-223 · American Airlines · N644AA

    64 killed, 125 on the ground
  4. American Airlines Flight 1 crashed in Jamaica Bay

    Jamaica Bay, New York, New York · Boeing B-707-123B · American Airlines · N7506A

    95 killed
  5. UPS MD-11F cargo jet crash at Louisville airport kills 15

    Louisville, Kentucky · McDonnell Douglas MD-11F · UPS Airlines · N259UP

    3 killed, 12 on the ground

Correct this page or send a photo

Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.

By sending a photo you confirm you took it and allow Air Crash DB to publish it with your credit. We keep your message and, if you give them, your name and email, until the correction is handled. See the privacy policy.