Fatal accident · United States
American Airlines Airbus A300 crash in Belle Harbor, Queens, after JFK takeoff
American Airlines Flight 587, an Airbus A300-605R, crashed into a residential area of Belle Harbor, Queens, New York, on November 12, 2001, shortly after leaving JFK for Santo Domingo. All 260 people aboard died, along with 5 people on the ground. The NTSB investigated and published its final report in October 2004.
This is one of 35 American Airlines fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 2001.
Read the cockpit voice recorder transcript
Vertical stabilizer separated minutes after takeoff
American Airlines Flight 587 crashed at about 9:16 a.m. Eastern Standard Time on November 12, 2001. It had taken off from John F. Kennedy International Airport, bound for Santo Domingo in the Dominican Republic, and came down in Belle Harbor, a residential neighborhood in Queens.
The flight followed another aircraft that had departed just before it. During the climb, the Airbus A300-605R met wake turbulence. The first officer made a series of rudder inputs in response. The resulting loads tore the vertical stabilizer and rudder off the fuselage. Both engines then separated, and the aircraft fell in an uncontrolled descent into the neighborhood.
Weather was not a factor. Visual conditions prevailed, and a 9:25 a.m. observation reported 10 miles of visibility and few clouds at 4,800 feet.
The aircraft and the people aboard
The aircraft was an Airbus A300-605R, registration N14053, operated by American Airlines. It was delivered new to the airline on July 12, 1988, making it about 13 years and 4 months old at the time of the crash.
There were 260 people on board, 251 passengers and 9 crew. All of them died. Five people on the ground also died. The sources available do not give a verified total for ground injuries.
What the NTSB found
The U.S. National Transportation Safety Board investigated the Belle Harbor crash and issued its final report, NTSB/AAR-04/04, on October 26, 2004. The report is titled In-Flight Separation of Vertical Stabilizer, American Airlines Flight 587.
The board's probable cause was that the vertical stabilizer separated in flight because of loads beyond ultimate design limits. Those loads came from the first officer's unnecessary and excessive rudder-pedal inputs. The NTSB also named contributing factors: characteristics of the A300-600 rudder control system, and elements of American Airlines' Advanced Aircraft Maneuvering Program. For more on how such findings are worded, see what probable cause means.
The investigation is closed. The accident is generally grouped with loss of control in flight events, although the structure failed first in this case.
The last minute of Flight 587, second by second
American Airlines Flight 587 was climbing out of JFK when the captain said "clean machine" at 09:15:29, meaning the gear, flaps and slats were retracted. Six seconds later the Airbus A300-605R was passing about 1,700 feet with its wings level. At about 09:15:36 the departure controller told the crew to turn left direct to the WAVEY intersection, about 30 miles southeast of JFK. The captain acknowledged at 09:15:41.
Between 09:15:50 and 09:15:58 the aircraft met wake turbulence from a Japan Airlines Boeing 747 that had departed ahead of it. The crew made repeated rudder-pedal inputs, each larger than the last.
The NTSB placed the fracture of the right rear main attachment fitting of the vertical stabilizer at 09:15:58.4. The stabilizer separated immediately afterward. The cockpit voice recorder picked up a loud bang at 09:15:58.5, with airspeed at about 251 knots.
The first officer said at 09:16:07.5, "what the hell are we into...we're stuck in it." The captain answered at 09:16:12.8, "get out of it, get out of it." The recording ended at about 09:16:14.8. The aircraft broke up and struck the ground in Belle Harbor shortly after.
N14053 had flown about 37,500 hours before Belle Harbor
The Airbus A300-605R registered N14053 had logged about 37,500 flight hours and 14,934 flight cycles by the day of the Belle Harbor crash. Those figures come from the Airbus submission to the NTSB docket. The NTSB report gives the build year as 1987, while the page's delivery date to American is July 12, 1988. The two are not in conflict, since one is manufacture and the other is delivery.
The material reviewed does not set out any earlier damage or repair history for the aircraft, so none is described here.
The weather information given to the crew was ATIS Delta. It reported wind from 330 degrees at 11 knots, visibility of 10 statute miles, few clouds at 3,400 feet, a temperature of 4 C, a dew point of minus 6 C and an altimeter setting of 30.42 inches. The cloud height differs from the 9:25 a.m. observation already given on this page, which was taken at a different time.
The NTSB found no sign in the cockpit voice recorder or air traffic control transcripts that the crew had received the later ATIS Echo broadcast. The board treated the wake encounter as the trigger for the control inputs, not as unusually severe turbulence.
Pilots, American and Airbus disagreed over where the blame belonged
The NTSB's finding on American Airlines Flight 587 was contested by several parties during the investigation. The Allied Pilots Association argued in its docket submission that the accident was an aircraft-pilot-coupling event driven largely by the A300-600 rudder system design, not mainly by pilot error. It asked for further engineering evaluation of the A300 and A310 rudder system and questioned whether training alone was an adequate fix.
American Airlines disputed the idea that its training program was a principal cause and wanted the rudder-control characteristics given more weight. Airbus contested parts of the NTSB's reading of how the rudder system behaved. It maintained that the aircraft met its certification requirements.
France's DGAC took part because Airbus is a French manufacturer. The NTSB addressed one recommendation directly to it.
These were technical disagreements inside the investigation. They did not produce a rival probable cause, and the NTSB's published conclusion did not change. For how such determinations are reached in general, see how investigators determine the cause.
Eight recommendations followed the Flight 587 report
The NTSB issued seven new safety recommendations to the FAA and one to France's DGAC after the Airbus A300-605R crash in Belle Harbor. They covered certification, aircraft design and pilot guidance.
- Revise 14 CFR Part 25 so that yaw-axis handling is safe across the flight envelope, including limits on rudder-pedal sensitivity.
- Review the A300-600 and A310 and modify them if needed to guard against hazardous rudder inputs at high airspeed.
- Warn pilots that repeated, alternating, near-full control inputs may signal an adverse aircraft-pilot-coupling event.
- State that flying at or below maneuvering speed does not guarantee structural protection from multiple full inputs in one axis, or full inputs in several axes at once.
- Train crews on rudder and vertical-stabilizer certification limits, and on the fact that high airspeed can make full rudder available with light, small pedal movements.
The FAA package also asked that instruction on legitimate rudder use, such as engine failure after takeoff and crosswind work, be kept in place.
The Atlantic reported that American changed its maneuvering guidance to warn that aggressive rudder inputs can damage an aircraft at any speed. The NTSB did not call for a blanket grounding of A300-600 aircraft. It also did not find air traffic control at fault, and the recommendations focused on control, design, certification and training.
Earlier A300 events at American Airlines
Before the Belle Harbor crash, American Airlines had several A300 events on record. UPI and a published accident list describe them, though they do not establish that all involved N14053.
- May 12, 1997: an A300 stalled on descent near Miami as Flight 903. The crew recovered and diverted, with one serious and one minor injury.
- July 9, 1998: an A300 lost an engine in London, then left the runway on landing.
- September 28, 1998: a takeoff was aborted in Paris after a horizontal stabilizer indication, with tire and brake damage.
- October 27, 1999: turbulence over Miami seriously injured one passenger.
- November 20, 2000: a fire after a return to Miami killed one flight attendant.
None of these is listed as a fatal crash of an A300 operated by American Airlines. Wider comparisons are on the accident history by aircraft model page.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened to American Airlines Flight 587?
American Airlines Flight 587, an Airbus A300-605R, lost its vertical stabilizer in flight shortly after leaving JFK on November 12, 2001. It crashed in Belle Harbor, Queens.
How many people died in the American Airlines Flight 587 crash?
All 260 people aboard died, 251 passengers and 9 crew. Five people on the ground in Belle Harbor also died.
What caused the American Airlines Flight 587 crash?
The NTSB found the vertical stabilizer separated because of loads beyond design limits from the first officer's excessive rudder-pedal inputs. It also cited the A300-600 rudder control system and American's training program as contributing factors.
Was Flight 587 caused by terrorism?
No. The NTSB final report attributed the crash to the in-flight separation of the vertical stabilizer after rudder inputs, not to a deliberate act.
Where did American Airlines Flight 587 crash?
It crashed into a residential area of Belle Harbor in Queens, New York, shortly after departing John F. Kennedy International Airport.
What aircraft was American Airlines Flight 587?
It was an Airbus A300-605R, registration N14053, delivered new to American Airlines in July 1988.
Did weather play a role in the Flight 587 crash?
No. Visual conditions prevailed with 10 miles of visibility. The aircraft did encounter wake turbulence from the aircraft ahead during its climb.
When was the Flight 587 final report published?
The NTSB published its final report, NTSB/AAR-04/04, on October 26, 2004.
Related accidents
- 92 killed
- 64 killed, 125 on the ground
- 271 killed, 2 on the ground
- 95 killed
- 160 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.