Fatal accident · Japan
China Airlines A300-600R crash on approach to Nagoya Airport, Japan
China Airlines Flight 140, an Airbus A300B4-622R registered B-1816, stalled and crashed during a go-around at Nagoya (Komaki), Aichi, Japan, on 26 April 1994. It was flying from Taipei. 264 of the 271 people on board died and 7 survived. Japan's Aircraft Accident Investigation Commission investigated and completed its report.
This is one of 13 China Airlines (Taiwan) fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1994.
A go-around lever pressed by mistake on final approach
China Airlines Flight 140 was a scheduled passenger service from Taipei, Taiwan, to Nagoya, Japan. On 26 April 1994 the Airbus A300B4-622R crashed near Nagoya Airport at Komaki, in Aichi Prefecture. The time is generally given as about 20:15 local time, though the sources available do not show the primary report's time entry.
There were 271 people on board, 15 crew and 256 passengers. 264 of them died. Seven survived with injuries. No deaths on the ground were reported.
The aircraft was on final approach when the problems began. The crew was flying an ILS approach, which uses ground radio beams to guide an aircraft down to the runway, and the first officer was handling the controls by hand.
How the approach turned into a stall
The FAA's summary of the Japanese investigation sets out the sequence for the China Airlines A300 on approach to Nagoya.
- The first officer was flying the ILS approach by hand and inadvertently pressed the GO lever on the throttles.
- Thrust increased and the flight director went into go-around mode.
- The autopilot was then engaged.
- The autopilot drove the horizontal stabilizer to full nose-up while the first officer kept applying nose-down elevator.
- The crew did not recognize that the trim and the elevator were working against each other.
- Angle of attack rose and the alpha-floor protection commanded more thrust.
- The captain took control and began a go-around, but the added thrust caused a rapid pitch-up and a further rise in angle of attack.
The aircraft stalled and crashed. In effect the stabilizer and the elevator were pushing in opposite directions, and the crew did not identify the conflict in time. This is a case of loss of control in flight with the automation engaged.
What Japan's investigators concluded
The Aircraft Accident Investigation Commission, then part of Japan's Ministry of Transport, investigated the Nagoya crash of the China Airlines A300 and completed its report. The investigation is closed.
The FAA's summary says the findings centered on flight-crew error. The crew misunderstood how the Airbus automatic flight system was designed, and how manual control inputs behave while the system stays engaged. The FAA names this as the principal cause, in the form of misunderstanding and inappropriate handling of the automatic flight systems.
The material available here does not give the full text of the report or its list of recommendations. It also does not describe the specific changes made to aircraft or procedures afterward, so none are listed. For how such findings are worded, see what probable cause means.
The aircraft and the operator
The aircraft at Nagoya was an Airbus A300B4-622R, registration B-1816, operated by China Airlines of Taiwan. Its age is not stated in the sources available. The FAA lists the crash in its lessons-learned library for transport airplanes, with links to the Japanese statement of causes and the accident report.
The FAA treats Flight 140 as an A300B4-622R accident, and the library is the place where it collects cases that show how crews and automated systems interact. A complete, verified list of earlier China Airlines or A300 accidents is not available here, so none is given. For comparisons across types, see accident history by aircraft model.
A four-year-old aircraft and a first officer with 1,033 hours on type
The Airbus A300B4-622R on China Airlines Flight 140, registration B-1816, was delivered new to China Airlines in 1990. It was about four years old when it crashed at Nagoya. Pratt & Whitney PW4158 engines powered it. Japan's Aircraft Accident Investigation Commission set out the aircraft and crew record in Report 96-5, approved on 15 July 1996 and published on 19 July 1996.
The commission found no pre-existing failure of the engines, flight controls or primary structure that caused the crash. The aircraft's total hours and landing cycles are in the report, but the extract available here does not reproduce them.
SKYbrary summarizes the crew figures from the report. The captain was 42 and had 8,340 flight hours, 1,350 of them on the A300-600R. He had spent 18 years in the Taiwanese Air Force, mostly flying C-47 aircraft, and logged 4,826 hours there. He joined China Airlines as a first officer in 1989, flew the Boeing 747, and became an A300-600R captain in 1992.
The first officer had 1,624 hours, including 1,033 on the A300-600R. He joined as a cadet and gained his commercial licence and A300-600R type rating in 1992. He was the pilot flying on the Nagoya sector.
The captain's takeover came late, and the nose reached about 53 degrees
On the ILS approach to Runway 34 at Nagoya, the report says the first officer moved the thrust lever through the go-around detent. The flight director switched to go-around mode, but the aircraft stayed near the approach path instead of climbing away. It then drifted above the normal glide path, and the crew answered the pitch-up with forward column input.
The cockpit voice recorder shows no immediate sign that either pilot recognized the go-around mode was still active. The captain said "I have got it" at about 11:15:03 in the report's time. This page keeps the commonly given local time of about 20:15, and the material available does not explain the gap. After the takeover the aircraft pitched up sharply, lost airspeed and stalled. An investigation summary puts the nose-up attitude at about 53 degrees. The aircraft struck the ground short of the runway.
The commission found weather was not a causal factor. No significant condition impaired the approach.
The aircraft burned within the airport area. Airport fire and rescue crews responded, but the fire and the destruction of the cabin hindered access. The report places the seven survivors in the less damaged rear of the cabin. The forward and central sections were destroyed by impact and fire. Seat numbers are in the report's survivor table, which is not reproduced here. For how survival varies between crashes, see plane crash survival rate.
Changes ordered at China Airlines within two weeks of the crash
After the Nagoya crash of Flight 140, Taiwan's Civil Aeronautics Administration acted before Japan's final report existed. A draft factual report, covering the flight and cockpit voice recordings, came out about two weeks after the accident.
On 3 May 1994 the administration ordered China Airlines to modify the flight-control computers on its A300-600R fleet, in response to an Airbus modification notice. On 7 May it ordered supplementary training and a proficiency re-evaluation for every China Airlines A300-600R pilot. The flight numbers CI140 and CI141 were retired and replaced by CI150 and CI151.
The investigation's recommendations centered on people more than hardware. They called for:
- better education on the design philosophy of advanced-technology aircraft
- stronger training on the automatic flight system
- improved cockpit-resource-management training
- instruction on recognizing mode confusion and conflicting control inputs
Summaries also list weak crew coordination and a failure to share an understanding of the aircraft's mode as contributing factors. The material available does not verify a Japanese regulation number, an air-traffic-control change or a mandatory Airbus hardware change tied only to this accident. The documented changes were the computer modification, training, proficiency checking and crew resource management.
The Nagoya court cleared Airbus and ordered China Airlines to pay
Families of the Nagoya victims took China Airlines and Airbus to court in Japan. In December 2003 the Nagoya District Court ordered China Airlines to pay about 5.026 billion yen to 232 plaintiffs, reported at roughly US$46 to 47 million. According to contemporary reporting, the court treated the pilots' conduct as reckless enough to lift the usual Warsaw Convention limit on liability.
The plaintiffs had argued that Airbus's design contributed to the crash. The court rejected that and found the aircraft not defective, so Airbus was cleared. Some families thought the award too low and went on with further claims. Those were settled in April 2007, when China Airlines apologized and paid additional compensation. No single verified total covering every settlement and insurance payment is available.
Contemporary reporting said the Nagoya District Public Prosecutor's Office sought to indict four senior airline officials over training and evaluation. The sources available do not give a reliable outcome, so no convictions are stated here. The wider argument over pilots, airline and manufacturer has continued in public discussion, though no formal dissent is attached to the Japanese report.
A memorial ceremony was held in Kasugai, Aichi, near the crash site, on the twentieth anniversary in 2014, with about 300 mourners reported. Another was held there on 26 April 2024 for the 264 victims.
What is not documented
For the China Airlines crash at Nagoya, the sources available do not give weather observations, the number of ground injuries, or the aircraft's age. The route and the absence of ground fatalities are commonly reported but are not shown in the FAA excerpt itself.
The exact local time of the crash is also approximate. Readers who want the primary detail can follow the FAA links to the Japanese report. For how reports like this are produced, see how investigators determine the cause.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened to China Airlines Flight 140?
China Airlines Flight 140, an Airbus A300B4-622R, stalled and crashed during a go-around at Nagoya (Komaki), Japan, on 26 April 1994.
How many people died in the China Airlines Flight 140 crash?
264 of the 271 people on board the Airbus A300 died at Nagoya. Seven survived with injuries.
What caused the Nagoya A300 crash in 1994?
Japan's Aircraft Accident Investigation Commission, as summarized by the FAA, focused on flight-crew error, including misunderstanding of the Airbus automatic flight system and the effect of manual inputs while it was engaged.
Where did China Airlines Flight 140 crash?
It crashed near Nagoya Airport at Komaki, in Aichi Prefecture, Japan.
What aircraft was China Airlines Flight 140?
It was an Airbus A300B4-622R registered B-1816, operated by China Airlines of Taiwan.
Who investigated the China Airlines Flight 140 crash?
The Aircraft Accident Investigation Commission of Japan, under the Ministry of Transport, investigated the Nagoya crash and completed a report.
Were there survivors in the Nagoya China Airlines crash?
Yes. Seven of the 271 people on board survived the China Airlines A300 crash at Nagoya, all with injuries.
Where was China Airlines Flight 140 flying from?
It was a scheduled flight from Taipei, Taiwan, to Nagoya, Japan.
Related accidents
- 225 killed
- 196 killed, 7 on the ground
- 520 killed
- 163 killed
- 68 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.