Fatal accident · Taiwan
China Airlines Airbus A300-600R crash near Taipei airport, Taiwan
China Airlines Flight 676, an Airbus A300-600R registered B-1814, crashed into a residential area near Taipei-Chiang Kai Shek International Airport, Taiwan, on 16 February 1998. All 196 people on board died, along with people on the ground. Taiwan's Civil Aeronautics Administration investigated and blamed crew actions.
This is one of 13 China Airlines (Taiwan) fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 1998.
A go-around in fog ended in a stall short of the runway
China Airlines Flight 676 was a scheduled service from Denpasar, Bali, to Taipei-Chiang Kai Shek International Airport, now Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport. On the evening of 16 February 1998 the Airbus A300-600R was making an ILS/DME approach to Runway 05L. Sources give the time as about 20:05 or 20:09 local time.
Reported conditions were light rain and fog, with a ceiling of 300 feet broken. One database summary says the aircraft was about 1,000 feet high at roughly 1.2 nautical miles from the threshold. A go-around began near the runway.
During the go-around, thrust was increased and the aircraft pitched up sharply. The landing gear was raised and the flaps set to 20 degrees. Pitch reached about 42.7 degrees and airspeed fell to about 45 knots before the aircraft stalled. It struck the ground about 200 feet left of the runway, hit a highway median and entered houses, where it caught fire. The aircraft was destroyed. This is a case of loss of control in flight.
The aircraft and the airline
The Airbus A300B4-622R, registered B-1814, was built in 1990 with serial number 578, so it was about seven and a half years old. It had two Pratt & Whitney PW4158 engines. China Airlines of Taiwan operated it. Its earlier history is not covered in the sources available.
China Airlines had lost another A300-600R in 1994. Flight 140 crashed at Nagoya, Japan, on 26 April 1994 after loss of control during a go-around, and 264 of the 271 on board died. That was a different aircraft, B-1816, but the same model. For wider context see airline safety records.
196 on board died, and the ground toll is disputed
The Aviation Safety Network records 196 people on board and no survivors. One secondary database gives 182 passengers and 14 crew. Nobody on the A300-600R survived the crash near Taipei.
The ground toll differs by source. The Aviation Safety Network lists seven deaths on the ground, while the Taipei Times summary of a contemporary report says six. The exact figure has not been settled in the available material, and this page uses seven as the Aviation Safety Network figure.
What the Civil Aeronautics Administration found
Taiwan's Civil Aeronautics Administration investigated the Flight 676 crash. Its final report is dated 18 May 2000 in the reference listings. The Taipei Times reported the conclusions in January 2000.
According to the sources, the crew flew the approach above the normal descent profile and did not properly intercept the glide path. Crew coordination during the go-around was inadequate. The aircraft's pitch-up tendency after thrust was applied went uncorrected for about 11 seconds, and the later response was inadequate, which led to an excessive nose-up attitude, stall and loss of control.
The Taipei Times also reported that the captain had disengaged the autopilot without realizing it had been released, that the procedures used on the second landing attempt were erroneous, and that China Airlines was criticized for insufficient training and poor cockpit resource management. For how such findings are reached, see what probable cause means.
The autopilot disconnected during the go-around and the crew did not notice
On China Airlines Flight 676 near Taipei, the sequence that mattered began when the crew started the go-around. The investigation found that a control-column input by the captain disconnected the autopilot on the Airbus A300B4-622R, B-1814. The crew did not recognize that the aircraft was no longer being flown automatically.
The crew apparently expected the aircraft to carry out the go-around on its own. No effective manual inputs were made for about 11 seconds. Increased thrust produced a nose-up pitch tendency, and the crew did not counteract it promptly. Pitch kept rising until the aircraft stalled and fell short of the runway.
The report also found that the approach itself was unstable. The aircraft was well above the normal descent profile and had not properly intercepted the glide path. Coordination between the captain and first officer during the go-around was inadequate, and the response that followed was inadequate too.
The Civil Aeronautics Administration criticized China Airlines for "insufficient training" and "poor management of the resources in the pilot's cabin." That second phrase is the report's wording for the cockpit resource management problem. It is not a finding that the aircraft malfunctioned. For how such findings are weighed, see how investigators determine the cause.
Early talk of an Airbus fault, and what the final report said
After the Flight 676 crash near Taipei, investigators first considered whether a software or flight-control problem on the A300-600R might have played a part. The accident looked similar to the 1994 China Airlines A300 crash at Nagoya, Japan, which is why the question came up. Taiwan also grounded China Airlines' nine A300-600R aircraft straight after the crash while authorities looked for answers.
The final conclusion did not blame the aircraft. It placed responsibility on the flight crew and on China Airlines' training and cockpit-management practices. The available material does not show that the final report attributed the accident to an Airbus software defect.
Nor does it record a formal dissent. No dissenting report from Airbus, France, Indonesia or any other authority has been found, and no public dispute between Taiwan's investigators and the manufacturer or the airline over the causes is documented. The investigation was run by a special task force under the Civil Aeronautics Administration, lasted nearly two years, and was reported as complete in January 2000.
Some web summaries describe the aircraft inconsistently or repeat conclusions without reproducing the report. The report itself and contemporary press coverage are the better guide.
Recommendations aimed at China Airlines and at Airbus
The investigation of the China Airlines Flight 676 crash near Taipei produced recommendations for both the airline and the manufacturer. They address the exact sequence of the accident: an unexpected change in automation mode, then no manual control.
For China Airlines, the recommendations were:
- Strengthen crew education and training on advanced flight-guidance-system functions.
- Reinforce training for rarely encountered events, including flight-mode changes and manual overrides during automatic flight.
- Provide cockpit measures that help crews recall those functions in flight.
- Make sure crews do not inadvertently activate the A300-600R go-around lever.
- Train crews to act correctly if it is activated by mistake.
For Airbus, the recommendations asked for a review of the A300's autopilot-disconnect and manual-override functions. The aim was that crews could control the aircraft safely at any altitude or flight phase once force above a set control-column threshold was applied. The report also called for better operational descriptions in the A300-600R Flight Crew Operating Manual.
The available material does not confirm any later change to Taiwanese regulations, a mandated cockpit redesign, an air traffic control procedure change or an Airworthiness Directive arising from this accident. See also accident history by aircraft model.
What is still not public about Flight 676
Several details of the China Airlines Flight 676 crash near Taipei are not available in the material reviewed. The crew's flight hours and experience are in the Civil Aeronautics Administration report but have not been reproduced in the sources found. The same applies to a full cockpit voice recorder transcript and to the emergency response timeline, including when fire services arrived.
One secondary page quotes an exchange with the tower, in which the aircraft was cleared to land with wind 360 degrees at 3 knots and the first officer read the clearance back. The extract does not say whether its time stamp is local or UTC, so no time is given here. The same page says one child was removed alive from the wreckage and died later. That is unconfirmed by the report.
A secondary database gives the aircraft's airframe total as 20,193 flight hours and 8,800 cycles. It has not been checked against the report. No nationality breakdown of the passengers has been found, and no memorial to the victims is documented.
The available results show no court verdicts, civil case outcomes or compensation figures specific to Flight 676. They also show no reopened inquiry and no later report replacing the 2000 findings. Material on litigation after the 1994 Nagoya crash is a separate matter.
Changes after the accident
The sources available do not describe specific regulatory or design changes that followed the Flight 676 crash, so none are stated here. The findings pointed mainly to crew training and cockpit resource management at China Airlines. Similar events are grouped under accident history by aircraft model.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened to China Airlines Flight 676?
China Airlines Flight 676, an Airbus A300-600R, stalled and crashed during a go-around at Taipei-Chiang Kai Shek airport, Taiwan, on 16 February 1998. It fell into a residential area and caught fire.
How many people died in the China Airlines Flight 676 crash?
All 196 people on board died. The Aviation Safety Network lists seven deaths on the ground, while the Taipei Times summary reports six.
Where did China Airlines Flight 676 crash?
It crashed near Taipei-Chiang Kai Shek International Airport, now Taoyuan International Airport, in Da-Yuan, Taoyuan, Taiwan. The aircraft hit the ground about 200 feet left of Runway 05L.
What caused the China Airlines Flight 676 crash?
Taiwan's Civil Aeronautics Administration attributed it mainly to crew actions. The approach was too high, the go-around was poorly coordinated, and a pitch-up went uncorrected until the aircraft stalled.
What aircraft was involved in Flight 676?
It was an Airbus A300B4-622R, also called an A300-600R, registered B-1814. It was built in 1990 and had two Pratt & Whitney PW4158 engines.
What was the route of China Airlines Flight 676?
The flight was a scheduled service from Denpasar-Ngurah Rai Airport in Bali, Indonesia, to Taipei in Taiwan.
Who investigated the Flight 676 crash?
Taiwan's Civil Aeronautics Administration investigated. Its final report is dated 18 May 2000.
What was the weather during the Flight 676 crash?
Reported conditions were light rain and fog, with visibility around 2,400 feet and a 300 foot broken ceiling. These figures come from a secondary database summary.
Related accidents
- 225 killed
- 264 killed
- 83 killed
- 110 killed
9 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.