Fatal accident · Taiwan

China Airlines Boeing 747 breakup over Taiwan Strait near Penghu, 225 killed

China Airlines Flight 611, a Boeing 747-209B registered B-18255, broke apart in flight over the Taiwan Strait near the Penghu Islands on 25 May 2002. All 225 people aboard died. Taiwan's Aviation Safety Council investigated, and the FAA summary attributes the failure to a poorly executed 22-year-old tail-strike repair.

This is one of 13 China Airlines (Taiwan) fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 2002.

Flight 611 lost contact 20 minutes after leaving Taipei

China Airlines Flight 611 was a scheduled passenger service from Chiang Kai-shek International Airport near Taipei to Hong Kong Chek Lap Kok International Airport. The Boeing 747-209B took off at about 15:07 local time on 25 May 2002.

About 20 minutes later, while climbing toward its cruising altitude, the aircraft lost contact with air traffic control. The summary from Taiwan's Transportation Safety Board places that point roughly 10 nautical miles northeast of Makung in the Penghu Islands. The official factual report gives the accident time as 15:29 local time (07:29 UTC) and the position as about 23 nautical miles northwest of Makung. Some databases round the time to 15:30.

Floating wreckage was sighted at about 18:00 local time in the Penghu area. Nobody survived. The aircraft was destroyed over the sea, so there were no deaths on the ground.

The 747 was 22 years old and had a tail-strike history

The aircraft involved in the Flight 611 accident was a Boeing 747-209B, registration B-18255, manufacturer's serial number 21843/386. It was built in 1979 and operated by China Airlines, which made it about 22 years old on the day of the accident.

On 7 February 1980 the aircraft suffered a tail strike while landing at Hong Kong's Kai Tak Airport. The aft lower fuselage was later repaired, and that repair became central to the investigation. For how accident records are compared across types, see accident history by aircraft model.

The sources used here do not give a complete list of earlier China Airlines accidents or of earlier 747 accidents, so no wider record is stated.

225 people died, though the crew breakdown differs by source

All 225 occupants of the China Airlines 747 were killed. Nobody aboard survived, and nobody on the ground died.

The official Taiwanese factual report lists 209 passengers and 16 crew members. A separate report hosted by the FAA gives 206 passengers and 19 crew. Both agree on the total of 225, and the Taiwanese figure is the one used on this page. This page does not name any of the people aboard.

Investigators traced the breakup to a fatigued repair

Taiwan's Aviation Safety Council (ASC), now associated with the Transportation Safety Board of Taiwan, led the investigation into the Flight 611 breakup. Its factual report found no evidence implicating air traffic services, weather, flight operations or the power plant as causal factors.

Radar data, flight recorders, the distribution of the wreckage and examination of recovered parts showed that the Boeing 747 suffered a catastrophic structural failure and broke apart in flight. The probable starting point was the aft lower fuselage, where the earlier tail-strike repair had been made.

The FAA's accident summary gives the most probable cause as structural failure at that 22-year-old repair. Scratches from the original tail strike had not been removed before the permanent repair doubler was installed. Fatigue cracking then developed and grew until the fuselage failed.

For how conclusions like this are worded, see what probable cause means. The same type of event is covered more broadly under mechanical failure crashes.

The Flight 611 investigation is finished and the reports are public

The investigation into the loss of China Airlines Flight 611 is complete. Final report volumes were published by the Taiwanese investigating authority, and the FAA hosts English-language copies of Volume 1 and Volume 2 on its website.

The FAA also lists the accident in its transport airplane lessons learned collection, where the focus is the inadequately executed repair on B-18255. The sources available do not describe specific regulatory or procedural changes that followed, so none are listed here.

To see how a case moves from first findings to closure, read preliminary vs final accident report.

Three men on the flight deck and no distress call

China Airlines Flight 611 had three crew on the flight deck, according to the Flight Operations Group material. The captain was 51 and had about 7,210 flight hours, 4,774 of them on the 747. The first officer was 52, with about 10,148 hours and 5,724 on the type. The flight engineer was 54, with about 19,180 hours and 1,615 on the 747.

The captain reported to the China Airlines dispatch office at 13:05 and received the operational briefing. The first officer and flight engineer reported at about 13:20. The cockpit voice recorder began recording at 14:56:12.

The Boeing 747 left Taipei at 15:07. At about 15:15 it contacted Taipei Area Control and was cleared to climb toward its assigned level, FL350, or 35,000 feet. Flight data recorder information showed no significant abnormality in the engines, flight controls or crew actions between 15:16 and 15:25. The initial structural failure came at about 15:27, and the breakup then moved quickly through the airframe.

Taipei Area Control lost radar contact at 15:28:03. The voice recording ended at the same moment. No Mayday or Pan-pan call was made, and the last air traffic exchange was routine. The report found no useful distress transmission from the crew. The 15:29 accident time used earlier on this page is the operational figure, about a minute after the recorded end of data.

Debris and bodies, but no survivors, were found from 18:00

After Flight 611 went down in the Taiwan Strait, Taiwan's authorities received the first accident notification at 15:36, according to the official factual chronology. That was about eight minutes after radar contact was lost. Search and rescue aircraft and vessels were sent toward the Penghu area.

The first rescue helicopters reached the accident area at about 18:00, roughly two and a half hours after the radar loss. Crews found a wide field of floating debris, traces of fuel and bodies. The official recovery report records 450 pieces of floating debris and 82 bodies recovered during the initial phase.

The response went on for days. It involved the Coast Guard, military units, helicopters, vessels, fishing boats and other civilian craft. Because the 747 had come apart at altitude and the wreckage was scattered over a large area of sea, recovery needed wide searches and later seabed and wreckage operations.

Investigators did not identify an intact cabin section or any seating area with survivors. Where people had been sitting was reconstructed from the passenger manifest, crew records and recovered remains. For what usually follows once a site is secured, see what happens after a plane crash.

The doubler covered the original damage and the cracks grew beneath it

The Taiwanese investigation into China Airlines Flight 611 found more than a single bad repair. The Aviation Safety Council concluded that after the 7 February 1980 tail strike, the damaged skin on B-18255 was not repaired in line with Boeing's Structural Repair Manual or another approved method. The repair used a doubler that neither removed nor restored the damaged structure. The report called it a non-conforming repair.

The original damage stayed under the doubler. Over the following years fatigue cracks formed and spread in the repaired area of the aft lower fuselage. They reached a critical size, the fuselage decompressed and the aircraft broke up. The aircraft had logged about 64,810 flight hours and 16,394 flight cycles by then. The report found no evidence of an explosion, a missile or a deliberate act.

It also named failures in continuing airworthiness at China Airlines:

  • The maintenance organization did not make sure the old repair was properly assessed and maintained.
  • Inspections and records did not identify or resolve the non-standard repair.
  • The self-audit and record systems were not effective enough.
  • Structural-aging programs and related airworthiness information were not fully implemented or addressed.

The factual report of 703 pages came out on 3 June 2003. The final report followed on 25 February 2005. How such conclusions are reached is covered in how investigators determine the cause.

Twenty-one recommendations went to six organizations

The Aviation Safety Council issued 21 safety recommendations after the loss of China Airlines Flight 611 over the Taiwan Strait. They went to China Airlines, Taiwan's Civil Aeronautics Administration, Boeing, the FAA, the Ministry of National Defense and the Ministry of Justice.

They called for structural repairs to follow the approved manual without deviation and for damage assessments to follow approved procedures. They asked for better repair record keeping and for operators to act on safety-related service information. Operators were urged to adopt the Repair Assessment Program and aging-structure requirements as early as practicable, and regulators to watch for better nondestructive inspection methods.

China Airlines said it scheduled early implementation of corrosion prevention and control tasks on affected 747-400 aircraft. The official sources do not document a single redesign of the 747 after the accident. The technical response centered on finding and managing repairs and cracks in aging structure.

The available official material does not give a full account of lawsuits or settlements, and no total compensation figure is verified. Families did bring claims against parties including China Airlines and Boeing. A memorial to the victims stands near Huxi Township in Penghu. The Council was later replaced by the Transportation Safety Board, which now hosts the reports. No reopening of the investigation has been identified.

What the official record does not settle

On China Airlines Flight 611, the total of 225 deaths is confirmed by the official report and by the Aviation Safety Network database. The split between passengers and crew is the only figure in dispute between sources.

Weather is also limited in the record. The Aviation Safety Council found no evidence that weather contributed to the accident near Penghu. The material available does not provide a minute-by-minute observation for the accident position, so details such as cloud, wind or turbulence are not stated.

The location is given two ways. The official factual report places the accident about 23 nautical miles northwest of Makung, while the FAA-hosted report describes wreckage sighted about 23 nautical miles northeast of Makung. Both put the event over the Taiwan Strait in the Penghu area.

Questions people ask about this accident

What happened to China Airlines Flight 611?

China Airlines Flight 611, a Boeing 747-209B, broke up in flight over the Taiwan Strait near the Penghu Islands on 25 May 2002. All 225 people aboard died.

What caused the China Airlines Flight 611 crash?

The FAA summary of the Taiwanese investigation gives structural failure at a 22-year-old tail-strike repair in the aft lower fuselage. Fatigue cracking had grown from scratches that were not removed during the repair.

How many people died on China Airlines Flight 611?

All 225 people aboard the Boeing 747 died, and no one on the ground was killed. The official report lists 209 passengers and 16 crew.

Where did China Airlines Flight 611 crash?

It came down in the Taiwan Strait, about 23 nautical miles northwest of Makung in the Penghu Islands, Taiwan, according to the official factual report.

When did China Airlines Flight 611 crash?

It crashed on 25 May 2002 at about 15:29 Taiwan local time (07:29 UTC), roughly 20 minutes after leaving Taipei.

Was weather a factor in the Flight 611 crash?

No. Taiwan's Aviation Safety Council found no evidence that weather contributed to the loss of the Boeing 747 near Penghu.

Who investigated the China Airlines Flight 611 accident?

Taiwan's Aviation Safety Council, now associated with the Transportation Safety Board of Taiwan, investigated and published the final report.

What was the history of the Flight 611 aircraft?

Boeing 747-209B B-18255 was built in 1979. It suffered a tail strike landing at Hong Kong Kai Tak on 7 February 1980, and the later repair was linked to the 2002 breakup.

  1. China Airlines Airbus A300-600R crash near Taipei airport, Taiwan

    Near Taipei airport, Taiwan · Airbus A300-600R · China Airlines · B-1814

    196 killed, 7 on the ground
  2. China Airlines A300-600R crash on approach to Nagoya Airport, Japan

    Near Komaki, Aichi, Japan · Airbus A300B4-622R · China Airlines · B-1816

    264 killed
  3. Singapore Airlines Flight 006 crashed on takeoff in Taipei

    Taipei, Taiwan · Boeing B-747-412 · Singapore Airlines · 9V-SPK

    83 killed
  4. Far Eastern Air Transport Flight 103 broke up near Sanyi

    Near Sanyi, Miao-li, Taiwan · Boeing B-737-222 · Far Eastern Air Transport · B-2603

    110 killed
  5. Learjet 60 crash in Greenacres, Florida kills all nine aboard

    Greenacres, Florida · Bombardier Learjet 60 · Private (LR60271 LLC) · N722BD

    9 killed

Correct this page or send a photo

Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.

By sending a photo you confirm you took it and allow Air Crash DB to publish it with your credit. We keep your message and, if you give them, your name and email, until the correction is handled. See the privacy policy.