Fatal accident · Brazil
TAM Airbus A320 crash at Congonhas Airport, Sao Paulo, kills 199
On 17 July 2007, TAM Flight 3054, an Airbus A320-233 flying from Porto Alegre, overran runway 35L at Sao Paulo Congonhas Airport and hit a TAM Express building and a fuel station. All 187 people on board died, as did 12 people on the ground. Brazil's CENIPA investigated and published report A-67/CENIPA/2009.
This is one of 6 TAM (Brazil) fatal accidents on record. See also all plane crashes in 2007.
The A320 overran runway 35L in the rain
TAM Flight 3054 was a scheduled passenger service from Porto Alegre/Salgado Filho Airport to Sao Paulo Congonhas Airport. The Airbus A320 departed at 17:19 local time and touched down at about 18:54 on 17 July 2007.
The landing was at night, in rain, on runway 35L, which was reported as wet. After touchdown the aircraft did not slow as intended and veered left. It overran the runway, crossed the airport boundary and struck the TAM Express building and a fuel station. The aircraft was destroyed by impact and fire.
This was a runway excursion that ended off the airport, in a built-up area. Nobody on board survived.
The aircraft and the thrust reverser
The Airbus A320-233 involved in the Congonhas accident was registered PR-MBK and operated by TAM Linhas Aereas. Accident reporting states that it landed with its right thrust reverser deactivated under the aircraft's minimum-equipment provisions. That is a permitted way to dispatch an aircraft with certain systems inoperative.
The aircraft's exact age at the time of the accident is not given in the sources reviewed. Details of the weather beyond rain and a wet runway, such as wind, ceiling and visibility, are also not covered in the published material available here.
199 deaths on board and on the ground
The Airbus A320 on Flight 3054 carried 187 people: 181 passengers and six active crew members. CENIPA records that all of them died. Twelve people were killed on the ground, in the TAM Express building, bringing the total to 199.
A consolidated figure for nonfatal injuries has not been confirmed in the sources reviewed. The names of those on board are not given here.
What CENIPA investigated and published
Brazil's CENIPA, the Aeronautical Accident Investigation and Prevention Center, led the investigation into the Congonhas crash. It completed the work and issued final report A-67/CENIPA/2009. The sources reviewed identify CENIPA as the investigating authority and do not indicate that the NTSB or FAA led the inquiry.
The analytical text of the final report was not available when this page was written, so its causal findings are not restated here. Claims that blame the accident on a single factor, such as pilot error, runway condition or one thrust lever fault, should be checked against the report itself. For how such findings are reached, see how investigators determine the cause and what probable cause means.
Where to read the official record
CENIPA publishes the English version of the TAM Flight 3054 final report on its website. Brazil's civil aviation authority ANAC also hosts a copy of the report, and ICAO holds a synopsis of the accident in its safety recommendations archive.
The final report is the document to read for the investigators' conclusions and any safety recommendations, which this page does not summarize. Readers comparing early press reporting with the outcome can see preliminary vs final accident report.
The thrust levers at 18:48 and the landing roll
TAM Flight 3054 left Porto Alegre at 17:19 and began its approach to Congonhas at about 18:20, according to a published timeline of the investigation. The pilots ran the landing checklist at 18:43. Air traffic control cleared the Airbus A320 to land on runway 35L at 18:47. At 18:48:24 the thrust levers were positioned incorrectly for the landing roll, and the aircraft touched down at about 18:54.
CENIPA found that PR-MBK landed with the number-two engine producing forward thrust, the ground spoilers retracted and the autobrake inactive. Published accounts say the crew knew the runway was wet and knew the right thrust reverser was unavailable. The cockpit voice recorder shows the crew discussing the failure to slow down and the apparent non-deployment of the spoilers.
The recorder was downloaded in the United States from 23 July 2007, and a transcript was released on 1 August 2007. The complete air traffic control and cockpit transcript is not reproduced here.
The occupant breakdown differs between sources. This page gives 181 passengers and six active crew. The final report, as summarized elsewhere, lists 176 passengers including two infants, six operating crew and five extra crew members. Both add up to 187.
Why CENIPA did not settle on pilot error alone
CENIPA's final report on the Congonhas crash described a landing roll in which the left thrust lever was moved to idle and reverse while the right lever stayed in the climb detent. The result was asymmetric thrust and continued high power, so the A320 could not slow or hold its line. The spoiler logic also did not deploy the spoilers, because the lever positions looked like a rejected takeoff rather than a landing.
The report listed several contributing factors:
- Incorrect thrust-lever positioning by the crew.
- A right thrust reverser that was deferred under the operator's minimum-equipment procedures.
- Insufficient understanding or execution of the one-reverser-inoperative procedure.
- Heavy rain, standing water and poor effective friction on the runway.
- Runway surface problems linked to earlier groove filling or repair.
- Small safety margins at an airport with a short runway and a fuel complex beyond it.
- Gaps in TAM's training and in how it passed on procedure changes.
- An aircraft design that could keep producing high forward thrust without an early, unmistakable warning.
The main technical dispute was whether the right lever was left in the climb detent by the crew or stuck for mechanical reasons. CENIPA considered the mechanical explanation and judged crew input more likely. France's BEA asked that the crew-related factors be worded as probable, in line with ICAO Doc 9756. That was a dispute over wording, not a rival finding. For the general idea, see what probable cause means.
The wet-runway ban and other changes after Flight 3054
CENIPA addressed a large set of recommendations to ANAC, airport authorities, TAM and Airbus after the Congonhas overrun. ANAC introduced a prohibition in April 2008 on operating at Congonhas on a wet runway with an inoperative thrust reverser.
The recommendations covered several areas:
- Runway friction monitoring, surface texture and drainage at Congonhas.
- Maintenance that avoids repairs reducing grooving or friction.
- A runway-end safety area, even if that meant shortening the declared runway length.
- Tighter operator control of deferred equipment when runway length or contamination leaves little stopping margin.
- Audits of TAM's operations, maintenance and training.
- Revised training for abnormal landing configurations and one-reverser operation, with both thrust levers returned to idle before reverse is selected.
- A review by Airbus of the ground-spoiler logic, the RETARD reminder, landing-deceleration logic and warnings for an unsafe thrust-lever configuration.
The report establishes the recommendations and the wet-runway restriction. It does not by itself show that every later Airbus alert change came from this accident.
No reopening of the inquiry has been reported since the final report. Later documentaries and academic papers have reexamined the runway condition and the thrust-lever question, but they are not new official findings. The accident is a case study in runway excursions.
Prosecutions, compensation and the Memorial 17 de Julho
Brazilian prosecutors brought criminal proceedings over the Congonhas accident against people linked to TAM and Infraero. The allegations centered on exposing the A320 to an unsafe landing configuration and on inadequate runway safety. The cases ran for years and did not end in a single outcome comparable to the technical report.
Families also sought civil compensation from TAM and others. Brazilian courts recognized claims for death, moral damages and loss of support, with awards varying by the victim's age, income and dependants. TAM settled with many families, and the amounts differed from claimant to claimant. CENIPA's investigation did not decide legal liability, since it works within the accident-prevention system and the courts apply separate standards.
A memorial stands on the site of the former TAM Express facility, where a mulberry tree survived the fire. It is commonly called the Memorial 17 de Julho, after the date of the accident, and it remembers the 199 people who died, 187 on board and 12 on the ground.
For the usual sequence of events after an accident, see what happens after a plane crash.
Earlier TAM and A320 accidents
The sources reviewed for the Congonhas accident do not give a reliable list of earlier accidents involving TAM or the Airbus A320 family, so none is cited here. The accident establishes the aircraft type and operator, but not a wider accident-history conclusion.
For broader context on how types compare, see accident history by aircraft model. The Boeing 737 vs Airbus A320 crash statistics page puts the A320 family in numbers.
Questions people ask about this accident
What happened to TAM Flight 3054?
TAM Flight 3054, an Airbus A320, overran runway 35L at Sao Paulo Congonhas Airport on 17 July 2007 and struck a TAM Express building and a fuel station.
How many people died in the TAM 3054 crash?
A total of 199 people died: all 187 on board the Airbus A320 and 12 people on the ground in Sao Paulo.
Were there any survivors of TAM Flight 3054?
No. CENIPA records that all 181 passengers and six crew on the A320 died.
Where did TAM Flight 3054 crash?
It crashed at Sao Paulo Congonhas Airport, Brazil, after overrunning runway 35L and leaving the airport perimeter.
What aircraft was TAM Flight 3054?
It was an Airbus A320-233, registration PR-MBK, flying from Porto Alegre to Sao Paulo for TAM Linhas Aereas.
Who investigated the TAM 3054 crash?
Brazil's CENIPA investigated the Congonhas accident and issued final report A-67/CENIPA/2009.
What were the conditions when TAM 3054 landed?
The A320 landed at night in rain on runway 35L, which was reported as wet. Its right thrust reverser was deactivated under minimum-equipment provisions.
What time did TAM Flight 3054 crash?
The Airbus A320 touched down at about 18:54 local time on 17 July 2007 at Sao Paulo Congonhas.
Related accidents
- 228 killed
- 154 killed
- 95 killed, 3 on the ground
- 137 killed
9 killed
Correct this page or send a photo
Spotted a wrong date, registration or number? Have a photo of the aircraft or the site that you took yourself? Send it here. Nothing is published until an editor has checked it.